Skip to main content

Appeals Court Resurrects RMBS Lawsuit Against Barclays

Mar 03, 2015

The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals has revived a lawsuit brought by the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA) that alleged Barclays Capital Inc. misrepresented the quality of more than $555 million in residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS), resulting in the failure of a pair of credit unions.

The NCUA lawsuit was first filed in September 2012 and alleged that Western Corporate Federal Credit Union and U.S. Central Federal Credit Union failed as a result of RMBS investments that went sour following a large number of defaults in the underlying mortgages. The case was dismissed by in July 2013 by U.S. District Judge John W. Lungstrum in Wichita, Kan., who stated that the charges were time-barred and the NCUA filed its case too late.

In its ruling today, the appeal court sided with the regulator, arguing that while the NCUA’s claims were filed six months past its deadline–the regulator was required to bring suit by March 20, 2012, three years after its appointment as conservator of the failed credit unions, but did not file its lawsuit until Sept. 25, 2012–Barclays nonetheless had agreed to “a series of tolling agreements that purported to exclude all time that passed during the settlement negotiations when ‘calculating any statute of limitations, period of repose or any defense related to those periods or dates that might be applicable to any Potential Claim that the NCUA may have against Barclays.’”

“Thus, while it is true that the NCUA’s claims are outside the statutory period and therefore untimely, that argument is unavailable to Barclays because the NCUA reasonably relied on Barclays’s express promise not to assert that defense,” said the court in reversing Judge Lungstrum’s decision.

About the author
Published
Mar 03, 2015
Fed Rate Could Be Down To 4.6% By Year's End

Inflation must hit its 2% goal for Fed to reduce rates.

New Compliance Requirements Add Challenges

Latest changes arrive at an already disruptive time in the mortgage industry

Changes Coming For Investment Properties

Using leases to qualify will require Proof

FCC Adopts New Rules To Close The 'Lead Generator Loophole'

Mortgage lead providers respond, saying this will "wipe out" several small and mid-tier businesses

Trade Associations & Lenders Stand Behind Trigger Leads Bill

Major trade associations like The MBA, NAMB, and BAC, urge action on S. 3502.

Supply And Demand Are Still Alive And Well

Treasury auctions may face weaker demand but they’re still getting done