Homeowner Sues Zillow Over Disputed Zestimate

May 11, 2017

In what is believed to be the first lawsuit of its kind, an Illinois homeowner is suing Zillow because the company’s Zestimate tool allegedly preventing the sale of her home by repeatedly undervaluing the property.

According to a Washington Post report, Glenview, Ill.-based real estate lawyer Barbara Andersen filed her lawsuit in Cook County Circuit Court with the charge that Zillow’s Zestimate of her townhouse was $562,000. Andersen is trying to sell the property for $626,000, which is close to what she paid for it in 2009, adding that larger houses directly across the street from her are selling for $100,000 more.

In her lawsuit, Andersen demands that Zillow should be licensed to perform appraisals and it should obtain “the consent of the homeowner” before posting this data online. She is seeking an injunction against Zillow to either remove the Zestimate attached to her property or to amend it; the lawsuit is not seeking monetary damages.

A Zillow spokesperson dismissed Andersen’s litigation as “without merit,” while the company’s website claimed its Zestimate “is not an appraisal” but an “estimated market value” based on a proprietary data formula.

About the author

Phil Hall

Link copied

Published

May 11, 2017

Opinion

Is United Wholesale’s Tale Indicative Of The Wholesale Market?

Questions over UWM’s capital structure, MSR valuations, and pricing strategy could carry consequences across the wholesale channel

The most recent UWM earnings report for the second quarter of 2026 garnered a lot of attention in the industry and has been sliced and diced in numerous ways. Proponents of UWM were quick to point out that the wholesaler has been a friend of brokers, and provided numerous bu...

Analysis and Data

Nearly Half Of Americans Would Consider A 3D-Printed Home

Consumer interest is growing, but concerns about durability, appraisals, code compliance, and resale value could complicate financing

Nearly half of Americans would consider buying a 3D-printed home if it met their location and budget needs, but concerns affecting the property’s value and marketability could create additional hurdles for lenders and loan originators.A new LendingTree survey found that 49% ...

Sep

San Francisco, CA

More from

Regulation and Compliance

Closing Costs: What HUD’s Proposed Rule Will Really Do To The Market

HUD’s proposed rollback of housing protections could deepen barriers for underserved borrowers, shrink the pool of prospective homebuyers, and ultimately cost loan originators business

Opinion

Aug 27, 2026

MISMO Gives Lenders A New Test For Mortgage AI Vendors

Two certifications move the industry’s FRAME initiative from governance guidance toward product-level validation and implementation

Tech

Aug 27, 2026

One Owner, Two GSEs: Would Fannie And Freddie Still Compete?

Oksenholt Capital says shared infrastructure could lower costs without weakening competition, but mortgage bankers have warned that common ownership could reduce lender choice, innovation, and market resilience

Analysis and Data

Aug 27, 2026

MaxClass: Education Meets Lead Generation

CEO Kelly Hendricks details how MaxClass and HomeQB are opening a new referral channel for originators

Regulation and Compliance

Aug 20, 2026

Fannie Mae Returns To Distressed-Loan Market With $214 Million Sale

The agency’s first nonperforming-loan offering in 13 months transfers 969 deeply delinquent mortgages to private buyers, including a small pool concentrated in Dallas-Fort Worth

Analysis and Data

Aug 20, 2026

Brief Refinance Shift Tests Mortgage Lenders’ Compliance Controls

Critical defect rate jumps 23.9% as math-based compliance findings expose the potential for one systemic error to affect loans across a lender’s book

Regulation and Compliance

Aug 20, 2026

Popular