Homeowner Sues Zillow Over Disputed Zestimate – NMP Skip to main content

Homeowner Sues Zillow Over Disputed Zestimate

May 11, 2017
In what is believed to be the first lawsuit of its kind, an Illinois homeowner is suing Zillow because the company’s Zestimate tool allegedly preventing the sale of her home

In what is believed to be the first lawsuit of its kind, an Illinois homeowner is suing Zillow because the company’s Zestimate tool allegedly preventing the sale of her home by repeatedly undervaluing the property.
 
According to a Washington Post report, Glenview, Ill.-based real estate lawyer Barbara Andersen filed her lawsuit in Cook County Circuit Court with the charge that Zillow’s Zestimate of her townhouse was $562,000. Andersen is trying to sell the property for $626,000, which is close to what she paid for it in 2009, adding that larger houses directly across the street from her are selling for $100,000 more.
 
In her lawsuit, Andersen demands that Zillow should be licensed to perform appraisals and it should obtain “the consent of the homeowner” before posting this data online. She is seeking an injunction against Zillow to either remove the Zestimate attached to her property or to amend it; the lawsuit is not seeking monetary damages.
 
A Zillow spokesperson dismissed Andersen’s litigation as “without merit,” while the company’s website claimed its Zestimate “is not an appraisal” but an “estimated market value” based on a proprietary data formula.  

 
About the author
Published
May 11, 2017
Condo Reserve Hike Could Restrict Financing, Trade Groups Warn

Five trade groups want FHFA to postpone tougher Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac requirements, warning that the changes could further restrict conventional condo financing

BAC Pushes CFPB to Change QM Broker Compensation Rules

Broker Action Coalition wants lender-paid broker compensation excluded from Qualified Mortgage fee calculations, arguing current rules put independent brokers at a disadvantage and discourage small-dollar lending

Rocket, Mr. Cooper Fined $6.75M Over Cybersecurity Failures

New York regulators say Rocket repeatedly failed to report security incidents, while Mr. Cooper's attackers exploited authentication weaknesses to access customer information

Newrez Agrees to $3 Million Settlement Over Servicing Violations

The $3 million Washington agreement follows a $15.5 million multistate settlement, with regulators citing problems involving escrow accounts, insurance charges, and payment processing

Nov 19, 2026
California Foreclosure Reform Could Reduce Delays for Servicers

Taking effect Jan. 1, the law narrows post-sale bidding eligibility and adds protections for foreclosure trustees, requiring lenders and servicers to update their procedures

Nov 19, 2026
FHA's Low-Rate Borrowers Boost Insurance Revenue as Lenders Push for Relief

FHA's annual report shows older loans are expected to generate more premium revenue as borrowers stay put, even as industry groups seek lower costs and an end to life-of-loan charges