Critical Defect Rate for Mortgages Inches Up

Sep 25, 2017

The critical defect rate for residential mortgages reached 1.61 percent during the first quarter, according to ACES Risk Management’s (ARMCO) latest Mortgage QC Trends Report. The first quarter figure was up from the 1.50 percent level in the previous quarter but down from 1.63 percent one year earlier.

The top defect category for the first quarter was Borrower and Mortgage Eligibility, which comprised 23.76 percent of all reported critical defects. This was followed by Income/Employment at 20.79 percent and Credit at 17.82 percent of all reported critical defects. Federal Housing Administration loans accounted for a disproportionately high number of critical defects, at 31.40 percent, followed by VA loans at 11.12 percent and USDA loans at 4.76 percent.

“The increase in the critical defect rate is the result of the purchase-dominated market we saw in the first quarter of this year,” said Phil McCall, president of ARMCO. “Purchase transactions bring a lot more moving parts, and a lot more opportunity for errors and misrepresentations. Whether that rate continues to rise will depend in large part on the ratio of purchases to refinances as we move forward.”

About the author

Phil Hall

Link copied

Published

Sep 25, 2017

Sales and Marketing

NMP Deep Dive: The AI Workforce

AngelAi demonstrates how AI agents can handle routine mortgage work, increase originator capacity, and reduce operating costs

Artificial intelligence is moving beyond answering questions and generating content. Increasingly, it can complete the routine work that consumes an originator’s day.That shift could allow mortgage companies to increase production without adding support staff at the same rat...

Analysis and Data

Higher Rates Cool July Mortgage Locks While Non-QM Pushes Past 10%

Purchase locks fell 12% from June as the conforming share dropped to 47.3%, extending the mortgage market’s shift toward more specialized products

Higher mortgage rates erased June’s improvement in borrower demand during July, but the retreat in overall activity concealed a continued shift in where mortgage production is coming from.Total rate-lock volume fell 11.4% from June as Optimal Blue’s benchmark 30-year conform...

Sep

Dallas, TX

More from

Regulation and Compliance

CHLA Uses Trump Mortgage Order To Renew Push For LO Comp Reform

Community lenders want more flexibility over employee compensation, closing-cost estimates, down payment assistance, and federal supervision of smaller IMBs

Regulation and Compliance

Aug 10, 2026

Servicers Begin Testing Systems Ahead of VA Partial Claim Deadline

VA lenders and servicers have until Nov. 28 to implement the new loss mitigation waterfall and Partial Claim Program

Regulation and Compliance

Aug 06, 2026

ROAD Act’s Housing Incentive May Be Too Small To Move Supply

Realtor.com finds the median city risks losing only about $84,000, although the policy could carry more weight in supply-starved Northeast and Midwest markets

Regulation and Compliance

Aug 05, 2026

CRA Proposal Could Reshape Bank Lending And Affordable Housing Investment

The OCC and FDIC would put more weight on lending while easing community development requirements for hundreds of banks

Regulation and Compliance

Aug 05, 2026

Fannie Mae AI Governance Deadline Arrives Aug. 6

Seller/servicers using artificial intelligence in origination or servicing must have formal policies, oversight, and vendor controls in place

Regulation and Compliance

Jul 31, 2026

Condo Review Deadline Puts Lenders On The Clock

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac will eliminate abbreviated project reviews for condo applications dated on or after Aug. 3