Critical Defect Rate for Mortgages Inches Up – NMP
Regulation and Compliance

Critical Defect Rate for Mortgages Inches Up

Sep 25, 2017

The critical defect rate for residential mortgages reached 1.61 percent during the first quarter, according to ACES Risk Management’s (ARMCO) latest Mortgage QC Trends Report. The first quarter figure was up from the 1.50 percent level in the previous quarter but down from 1.63 percent one year earlier.
 
The top defect category for the first quarter was Borrower and Mortgage Eligibility, which comprised 23.76 percent of all reported critical defects. This was followed by Income/Employment at 20.79 percent and Credit at 17.82 percent of all reported critical defects. Federal Housing Administration loans accounted for a disproportionately high number of critical defects, at 31.40 percent, followed by VA loans at 11.12 percent and USDA loans at 4.76 percent.
 
“The increase in the critical defect rate is the result of the purchase-dominated market we saw in the first quarter of this year,” said Phil McCall, president of ARMCO. “Purchase transactions bring a lot more moving parts, and a lot more opportunity for errors and misrepresentations. Whether that rate continues to rise will depend in large part on the ratio of purchases to refinances as we move forward.”
About the author
Phil Hall
Link copied
Published
Sep 25, 2017
Get the NMP Daily
Community
How To Win Real Estate Investors, And Keep Them Coming Back

NMP Ignite speakers share strategies for building lasting investor relationships, overcoming financing challenges, and generating repeat business

Real estate investors can be some of the most valuable clients an originator will ever work with. They buy repeatedly, refinance properties, build portfolios, and refer other investors. But earning their loyalty requires a different approach from traditional residential lend...

Continue reading
Analysis and Data
Just 22% Of Homebuyers Are First-Timers As Cash Purchases Rise

NAR finds nearly one-third of repeat buyers pay cash, narrowing the pool of financed purchase transactions for lenders

First-time homebuyers remain largely on the sidelines of the housing market, accounting for just 22% of purchases as older, equity-rich repeat buyers continue to dominate, according to new data from the National Association of Realtors (NAR).The first-time buyer share edged ...

Continue reading
Renew your NMLS License — for free.

Enjoy access to a free NMLS renewal class when you attend an in-person event.

Find an event
More from
Regulation and Compliance
West Capital LO Challenges Contractor Status, Required Fees

A former originator alleges unpaid overtime, recurring tech charges, and company restrictions that he says undermine his independent-contractor status

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 06, 2026
CFPB Closes 40% Of Investigations, Keeps Mortgage Enforcement In Focus

The federal watchdog closed thousands of supervisory and investigative matters as it narrowed oversight

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 05, 2026
Midterms Loom With Mortgage Policy Changes Already In Motion

As voters head to the polls Tuesday, Washington is weighing changes to refinancing costs, loan pricing, and lending regulations

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 02, 2026
UAD 3.6 Deadline Is Monday. Are Brokers Ready?

Wholesale lenders have adopted different rules for appraisal transfers, loan product changes, and reporting formats, adding complications for brokers and appraisers ahead of the Nov. 2 mandate

Regulation and Compliance
Oct 27, 2026
Friday Harbor Expands AI Appraisal Reviews As UAD 3.6 Deadline Nears

The new capability adds more than 350 automated checks as lenders prepare for the November 2 mandate

Tech
Oct 27, 2026
The Hidden Cost Of Appraisal Uncertainty

As home equity lending grows, lenders need a better way to resolve conflicting property evidence before it creates costly setbacks

Regulation and Compliance
Oct 25, 2026