Skip to main content

NAR and Real Estate Brokerages Face Class-Action Lawsuit

Phil Hall
Mar 11, 2019
The U.S. Department of Housing & Urban Development (HUD) has charged Plano, Texas landlords Quang Dangtran and his wife, Ha Nguyen, with violating the Fair Housing Act by refusing to lease a room to a prospective tenant because she is African-American

An anti-trust class action lawsuit has been brought against the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and four prominent real estate brokerage firms—Warren Buffett’s HomeServices of America, Keller Williams, Realogy and RE/MAX—over allegations of inflated commission rates and anticompetitive practices.
The lawsuit, filed on Mar. 6 in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, accuses NAR and the four companies working together to maintain a lock in 25 major markets that prevents competition from other brokerages and forces home sellers, home purchasers, and real estate brokers from negotiating over the commissions that sellers pay for the transaction.
“When you compare commission rates in these affected housing markets to those in countries with competitive real-estate broker markets, the numbers tell a very clear story,” said Steve Berman, Managing Partner of Hagens Berman and attorney representing home sellers in the class action. “We believe that NAR and the Big Four have devised a series of checks on broker commission rates to all but guarantee their goal of price-fixing, costing home sellers thousands in excessive commissions paid on each sale.”
The lawsuit charges NAR and the companies with violating the Sherman Act by only allowing listing brokers to list a property on an MLS if the listing broker makes a unilateral, non-negotiable offer of compensation on the MLS to buyer brokers. Real estate brokers cannot disclose from disclosing commissions offered on MLS, the lawsuit adds, and also allows brokers to take both buyer and seller commissions, if the buyer is not represented by a broker.
“Under these policies straight out of NAR’s handbook, sellers suffer, and brokers reap the spoils,” Berman said. “NAR and the Big Four are doing absolutely everything in their power to restrict and control real-estate broker commissions, and our antitrust team intends to put an end it.”
Plaintiffs in the case are also represented by attorneys at Cohen Milstein, Handley Farah & Anderson, Justice Catalyst Law, Wright Marsh & Levy and Teske Katz Kitzer & Rochel.

Mar 11, 2019
Mortgage Malaise: CFPB Report Reveals Steep Originations Drop, Rising Borrower Costs

Increased fees, soaring monthly payments, and growing approval disparities unsettle the housing market; CFPB eyes regulatory tweaks.

Sep 27, 2023
CFPB Unveils Plan To Remove Medical Debt From Credit Reports

Vice President Harris and CFPB Director Chopra highlight potential boost in mortgage approvals and question debt collectors' methods.

Turning The GSEs’ Repurchase Policies Into Opportunity

Lenders selling to Fannie and Freddie have to take swift action and enact robust strategies to mitigate risk

The ‘Science’ Of Appraisals Gets Government Attention

Start now to prepare your Reconsideration of Value policy

Michael Eising Receives MBA Legacy Achievement Award

Indiana banker honored for three decades of service to mortgage compliance.

Rejected Mortgage Applicants Get Another Chance

FHA waiver removes the scarlet letter from denied borrowers.