Letter to the Editor: Net Branching is Not Per Se Unacceptable to HUD
When Real Estate Can Be Haunted By The PastJames Ystesundtitle insurance, chicago title
What does a self-styled descendant of the Spanish Conquistadors have to do with one of the
nation's largest title insurance organization? Ask Chicago Title, who will tell you of numerous
trips to an Albuquerque, New Mexico courtroom to successfully defend against this alleged
conquistador's claim that a client's real estate belongs to him by virtue of an ancestral Spanish
Land Grant. The lesson?
"When you own real estate, someone else's past can come back to haunt you," said Ron Antoine,
Resident Vice President and Wisconsin State Manager of Chicago Title Insurance Company.
While most types of insurance protect people from harm that may occur in the future, title
insurance does exactly the opposite, it insures against harmful events that may have already
occurred, but are unknown at the time the title is transferred. Unlike other types of insurance, a
title policy protects the holder the entire time he or she owns the land-for only the cost of a
one-time premium payment.
Take The Case of the Missing Heir. While a man named Jackson was developing a piece of
property he purchased, a claim was filed against the property on behalf of Dan Smith. Mr. Smith
believed that his father was the illegitimate son of the man who owned the property 40 years
before, and therefore should have inherited a portion of the property. He sought to force Mr.
Jackson to subdivide the property, or sell it and divide the proceeds with him.
In such cases, it is critical that the owner of the land have, in force, a title policy with a company
that stands prepared to defend all claims, regardless of how far in the past they may originate.
That's because, in title disputes, time does not cure all defects in the title. And even a small
claim, if successful, could force the sale of the property.
A title insurance policy holds the insurers responsible for defending against such claims. Without
such a policy, the owner would have to bear the burden of research, legal, and court costs, in
addition to the loss of some or all of the property if the title cannot be defended successfully.
These costs may far exceed the cost of a single premium title policy. Even if a claim is defended
successfully, there are no guarantees against a claim arising from another source, starting the
expensive process again.
In the case of Smith and Jackson, Chicago Title Insurance Company conducted an extensive
review of the chain of title records, as well as the family's birth, death, and marriage records, to
find that there was insubstantial evidence to support Mr. Smith's paternity claim.
In addition, a study was conducted of inheritance and paternity law from the company's vast
database of cases pertaining to land title questions. This investigation helped Chicago Title
successfully defend its customer's right to retain and develop the land.
A number of title problems can arise to haunt a property owner, including:
++Title Forgery. When a forgery is found, every subsequent transaction can be declared null and
++Technical Fault. If found in a previous transfer, a technicality such as an improperly handled
foreclosure can render the title invalid.
++Hidden Defect. This occurs when the defect could not be discovered prior to the transfer of
title. For instance, while digging a new swimming pool, a property owner may discover that his
or her neighbor's septic tank system is buried in his or her backyard.
When purchasing property, it is important to remember that every conveyance or encumbrance of
a parcel of land creates the possibility of a title problem. And whether that problem occurred six
months or 60 years ago, the best method of protection is the purchase of a title insurance policy
from a company that is prepared to defend it as many times as necessary, for as long as the
property is owned.
James Ystesund is Business Development Manager with Chicago Title Insurance Company. He
can be contacted at (414) 796-9651 or fax (414) 796-3888, or E-mail Ystesund@CTT.com.
FMJ Job Listings
- Underwriter - CBRE - Newport Beach, CA
- Senior Vice President, Marketing - Alaska USA Federal Credit Union - Anchorage, AK
- VAS - Vice President - CBRE - Boise, ID
- Underwriter - CBRE - Oak Brook, IL
- External Mortgage Loan Officer - Anheuser-Busch Employees' Credit Union - St. Louis, MO
- Chief Lending Officer - Credit Union of Georgia - Woodstock, GA