Skip to main content

Forward on reverse: Insights for marketing to maturity: Part VI: A different kind of customer

National Mortgage Professional
Jun 22, 2006

Is there a place for AVMs?D. Cameron Rogers and Wayne B. BzdulaAutomated valuation models Did the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency's (OCC's) guidance memo of May 2005 make you wonder about your institution's use of alternative approaches to appraisals? If so, you're not alone. Soon after the release of "Credit Risk Management Guidance for Home Equity Lending," many lenders started re-examining their home equity lending practices in view of the memo's goal of promoting "sound credit risk management practices for institutions engaged in home equity lending ... " Do automated valuation models (AVMs) still have a place in a lender's closing toolkit in light of the OCC memo? We believe so. In fact, the memo put down in writing some of the important considerations that we have been advocating for years about sound credit risk management practices. Here are a few tips to help lenders evaluate which situations make sense for AVM usage: Know your own risk appetite From a risk management perspective, each lender needs to understand his institution's tolerance for risk. Lenders need to develop their own risk reward analyses or equations. These should be based on safety and soundness, loan size, collateral profile, credit, collateral reliance, operating efficiencies and cost objectives. These policies will shape their strategy for deciding on the methods that they apply for value determination. Develop a policy Lenders need to develop a set of polices that assure them that what they are doing to value real estate is appropriate. These policies should put risk parameters in writing and give guidance about the most appropriate valuation methodology to use under different circumstances. Naturally, they will be developed around the notion of equating risk with cost. Often, our clients develop a matrix to simplify the process. It might recommend that, for example, a customer with a high credit score and low debt-to-income or low loan-to-value would be an appropriate candidate for a quicker, less expensive means of doing collateral evaluations, like an AVM. As risk parameters indicate a greater degree of risk, then a more thorough evaluation of collateral might well be indicated. Understand what AVMs can deliver AVMs provide an independent, unbiased determination of value. They can be used alone, with or without an insurance enhancement, or in conjunction with other valuation methods as part of a validation strategy. The attraction of AVMs is that they determine property values almost instantaneously, not in two to three weeks like traditional approaches. In addition, they reduce costs and processing time, two critically important competitive advantages in today's marketplace. Understand the market In the home equity market, the name of the game is "speed to decision." There's no ignoring the fact that speed to decision can lead to larger market share. You know your competitors are trying to convince borrowers that they need home equity lines of credit. "It's a simple process, so why not get it?" they ask in their ads. You also know that any time you throw up an obstacle, like an appointment for a formal appraisal, you lose the consumer's interest. AVMs can be one of the key components to overcoming consumer reluctance, because they eliminate obstacles. When used correctly, they deliver speed, without sacrificing safety and soundness. Partner with the right provider Especially in light of the OCC guidance, it is particularly important that lenders work with recognized providers that offer a range of services. These providers also need to be able to design a program to match a lender's needs that includes documenting criteria for choosing one method of valuation over another. Develop your programs on the assumption that you will need to be able to support your decisions with data and provide that data to the regulators. Experienced vendors should be able to help in that process. They should provide tools to help lenders build the justification for the risk programs they design. In short, we believe that the OCC guidance memo was a wake-up call to lenders. Federal regulators acknowledged that the rapid, ongoing evolution in collateral valuation practices is something that they haven't kept up with. But, that may soon change. Right now, they have no formal policy guidance for AVMs, but the memo suggests that creating such guidance is a "top priority." Until the regulatory landscape for AVMs becomes clear, we advise lenders to adopt best practices—to document to the greatest extent possible why they chose one valuation method over another and to continue to respond to the needs of the marketplace with the most appropriate valuation approach. In the end, lenders will need to develop their own risk acceptance criteria around the notion of equating risk with cost, and then be prepared to document the reasons for those criteria. D. Cameron Rogers is a senior vice president in Fiserv Lending Solutions valuation services. Wayne B. Bzdula is a senior vice president and director of risk management for Fiserv Lending Solutions. They may be reached at (800) 842-8423 or e-mail [email protected] and [email protected], respectively.
Published
Jun 22, 2006
ChainLogix Appoints New Vice President, Operations

Jeryl Graham hired to accelerate growth in title & mortgage services.

Industry News
Oct 15, 2021
JPMorgan Chase To Commit $8.4M To Improve Household Stability For The Underserved

JPMorgan Chase announced six organizations that will receive philanthropic capital as part of the firm’s $400 million five-year commitment to improve housing affordability and stability for Black, Hispanic and Latino, and other underserved households.

Community
Oct 15, 2021
SRE Mortgage Alliance 'Restructuring & Reorganizing'

UPDATE: Owner of technology-based wholesale residential mortgage lender in El Segundo to determine organization's future.

Wholesale
Oct 15, 2021
Ginnie Mae Issued Record MBS Volume In FY2021

The record $939 billion issued included nearly $73 billion in September.

Industry News
Oct 14, 2021
UWM Completes Test Of Cryptocurrency Mortgage Payments

United Wholesale Mortgage evaluated and accepted the first-ever cryptocurrency mortgage payment in September and an additional five payments in October from borrowers.

Industry News
Oct 14, 2021
Arvielo Re-Appointed To HUD Advisory Committee

Nationwide mortgage lender New American Funding’s Co-Founder and President Patty Arvielo has been re-appointed to serve on the U.S. Department of Housing & Urban Development's Housing Counseling Federal Advisory Committee.

Industry News
Oct 13, 2021