Minnesota woman pleads guilty in $400,000 mortgage fraud scheme – NMP Skip to main content

Minnesota woman pleads guilty in $400,000 mortgage fraud scheme

Jul 09, 2010

Sharon Michelle Thomas from the central Minnesota city of Otsego has pleaded guilty in federal court to participating in a mortgage fraud scheme that resulted in a $400,000 loss to several mortgage loan lenders. Appearing in St. Paul, Minn. before United States District Court Judge Richard H. Kyle, Thomas pleaded guilty to one count of aiding and abetting mail fraud. In her plea agreement, Thomas admitted that from 2005-2006, she assisted others in obtaining money through fraudulent pretenses by depositing 10 “closing packages” in the U.S. mail or with private commercial carriers. During this time, Thomas was a closing agent for a licensed title company, which was affiliated with a local builder and closed residential real estate transactions for the builder. Thomas provided documents to mortgage loan companies that were funding the mortgage loans for each residential transaction, after which the lenders would approve loans and provide loan proceeds to the title company. Thomas admitted concealing from the lenders payments she made to “investors” associated with Superior Investment Group (SIG) on 10 Minnesota properties. Thomas admitted receiving only her customary salary and small bonuses for closing the transactions. SIG was owned and operated by Troy David Chaika of Burnsville, Minn. and Dustin Lee LaFavre of Webster, Minn. The two men conspired to obtain money fraudulently through approximately 183 residential property transactions that defrauded real estate mortgage lenders out of more than $7 million. LaFavre pleaded guilty to one count of conspiracy to commit mail and wire fraud and awaits sentencing. Chaika has been indicted on seven counts of wire fraud, three counts of mail fraud, one count of conspiracy to commit wire fraud and mail fraud. For her crime, Thomas faces a potential maximum penalty of 20 years in prison. Judge Kyle will determine her sentence at a future date, yet to be scheduled. This case is the result of an investigation by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) and the U.S. Postal Inspection Service. For more information, visit http://minneapolis.fbi.gov.
About the author
Published
Jul 09, 2010
FHA Sets Jan. 1 Start For FICO 10T And VantageScore 4.0

Lenders will gain competing modern scoring options, but borrowers may not see both offered everywhere

Sep 11, 2026
FHFA Studies Credit-Report Changes To Cut Mortgage Costs

Pulte’s comments could signal either fewer bureau reports or a portable report borrowers could share among lenders, but FHFA has not clarified which approach it is studying

AI Errors Leave Mortgage Trustee Without Brief In Foreclosure Appeal

Outside counsel’s fabricated citations expose a third-party oversight risk for mortgage servicers, trustees, and investors

Sep 10, 2026
CHLA Wants Ginnie Mae Liquidity Backstop Ready Before Next Crisis

Proposed G-TALF facility could help prevent a servicing cash crunch from constraining FHA, VA, and USDA lending

FHFA Opens VantageScore To All GSE Lenders, Eyes Credit Report Overhaul

Pulte removes 50-lender cap while considering bi-merge and single-bureau reports as additional ways to reduce mortgage costs

Closing Costs: What HUD’s Proposed Rule Will Really Do To The Market

HUD’s proposed rollback of housing protections could deepen barriers for underserved borrowers, shrink the pool of prospective homebuyers, and ultimately cost loan originators business

Aug 27, 2026