Skip to main content

Do Smaller Markets Offer Better Deals for Renters?

May 01, 2015

While almost all current data indicates it is more cost-effective to buy a home than to rent, that is not to say that renting is a 100 percent lose-lose situation.

A new study from Realtor.com finds that rents can get a great value if they focus on smaller city markets of 50,000 people or less. Leading the list as the most renter-friendly market is Los Alamos, N.M., followed by Columbus, Neb.; Summit Park, Utah; Spirit Lake, Iowa; Kearney, Neb.; Bismarck, N.D.; Cedar Rapids, Iowa; Grand Island, Neb.; Iowa’s Des Moines-West Des Moines metro area; and Madison, Wis.

Nonetheless, Realtor.com Chief Economist Jonathan Smoke noted that affordable homeownership is easily located in all of these markets, with the possible exceptions of Summit Park and Bismarck.

“Renting is not a wise long-term financial choice if you intend to live in a market beyond a break-even amount of time and you can afford to buy,” Smoke said.

On the flip side, Smoke noted that major metro areas are still rich with “buyer bargains” in housing, with Atlanta offering the best opportunities in affordable homeownership.

“Atlanta has always been more affordable, despite having seen very strong population growth for decades,” Smoke said. “There’s no natural barrier like an ocean or mountains or desert that limits development—so new construction has kept supply in balance with demand.”

Other “buyer bargain” metro areas include Chicago, Philadelphia, Detroit, Tampa-St. Petersburg, St. Louis, Pittsburgh, Cincinnati, Indianapolis and Virginia Beach-Norfolk-Newport News.

“Our top markets for buying generally didn’t see the kind of price appreciation in the housing boom that the true bubble markets saw—and many of them, such as Detroit, actually went through turbulent economic times” Smoke said.

About the author
Published
May 01, 2015
Homebuilders Cheer Delay Of Trump Trade War

Canada and Mexico stave off tariffs on billions of dollars of materials crucial to the U.S. homebuilding industry

Feb 04, 2025
OCMBC President Arrested For DUI, Murder

Serene Vernon (Rosenberg) had three prior convictions, per a police report

Feb 02, 2025
Trump Fires CFPB Director Chopra

Chopra posts a letter to X with his final statements

American Heritage Lending Halts Funding Loans In Maryland

AHL suspended the ability to lock new consumer loans in Maryland, effective immediately

Jan 31, 2025
Katie Sweeney Joins Rocket Pro To Lead Broker Strategy, Advocacy

The former AIME chairwoman and CEO asks the broker community, particularly Rocket Pro’s brokers, to trust her. 

Jan 29, 2025
CoreLogic Chief Economist On Witnessing The Insurance Crisis Firsthand

"I could have lost all my equity,” says Selma Hepp, who lives and works on the frontline of housing's biggest challenge in 2025

Jan 20, 2025