CUNA Criticizes CFPB Again on HMDA Data – NMP Skip to main content

CUNA Criticizes CFPB Again on HMDA Data

Phil Hall
Jan 15, 2016
The Credit Union National Association (CUNA) is continuing its criticism of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), with a new op-ed column in the influential Washington, D.C.-based media source The Hill that blasts the agency for heavy-handed re

The Credit Union National Association (CUNA) is continuing its criticism of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), with a new op-ed column in the influential Washington, D.C.-based media source The Hill that blasts the agency for heavy-handed regulatory oversight of credit unions.

In the op-ed, CUNA Chief Advocacy Officer Ryan Donovan repeats a recent statement by CFPB Richard Cordray that absolved credit unions of playing any role in the housing bubble and the subsequent 2008 economic meltdown, but questions whether Cordray’s agency is aware of his comments.

“Unfortunately, instead of zeroing in on those in the marketplace who caused the financial crisis, the CFPB has insisted on lumping credit unions in with those bad actors and continues to sweep them into rulemakings that should be aimed at unscrupulous participants in the financial marketplace,” Donovan wrote. “The Bureau’s broadsword approach to rulemaking has a tragic consequence: the very consumers it seeks to protect are harmed because financial services offered by credit unions could become more expensive and less available. The CFPB’s rules have created an overwhelming regulatory burden that has prompted some credit unions to stop offering certain services, leaving members with no choice but to turn to less reputable providers, or even predators in the marketplace.”

Donovan pointedly argued that Cordray was not entitled to “his own set of facts” in regard to the impact of CFPB regulations on credit unions, particularly in regard to home loans.

“Just take a look at the recently finalized Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) rule that nearly triples the amount of new data fields that must be collected–far beyond what is required by statute,” he continued. “This will be extremely damaging for credit unions, especially given that nearly half of all credit union loans are mortgage-related. This regulation will unquestionably force some smaller institutions out of the marketplace, decrease consumer choice, and limit affordable options for millions of consumers.”

Donovan sharply added that the CFPB was straying beyond its Dodd-Frank Act parameters and consumer would benefit from this situation.

“Consumers deserve a CFPB that–as the law requires–takes into consideration the impact its rules will have on their ability to access credit and–as the law specifically allows–exempts credit unions from rules designed to reign in the abusers of consumers,” he said. “If the Bureau doesn’t do this, the only financial services providers left standing will be the ones Director Cordray has recognized as having caused the financial crisis. Once again, credit unions are here sounding the alarm. We can only hope that this time, someone is listening.”

The op-ed in The Hill is the latest public criticism that CUNA leveled against the CFPB. Over the past month, CUNA has challenged the agency on HMDA data collecting and whether the CFPB is meeting its goals of serving the needs of consumers. Last March, CUNA joined several trade associations in voicing support for proposed congressional legislation that would replace the office of the CFPB director with a bipartisan commission.

Published
Jan 15, 2016
CFPB Seeks Insight On Creating A Fairer Mortgage Market

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has been actively looking to create a fairer mortgage market, free of discriminatory engagements. To do so, it issued a Request for Information to seek input on rules implementing the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act.

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 17, 2021
Regulators Renew Effort to Protect Against Foreclosures

CFPB, The Fed, FDIC and other agencies will watch for compliance with COVID-19 protections

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 10, 2021
Fed To Begin Tapering Asset Purchases by 14.3% This Month

Also sets target range for the federal funds rate at 0 to 1/4%.

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 03, 2021
CFPB Cracks Down On Discriminatory Credit Reporting For Black And Hispanic Consumers

Consumers in majority Black and Hispanic neighborhoods are far more likely to have disputes appear on their credit reports. 

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 03, 2021
CFPB Names 2 New Assistant Directors

Former Obama Administration officials will lead Supervision Policy, Enforcement divisions.

Regulation and Compliance
Oct 29, 2021
FHFA Proposes Extra Disclosure Rules For Fannie, Freddie

The proposed rule for the Enterprise Regulatory Capital Framework seeks to put Enterprises on a "level playing field" with U.S. banking requirements.

Regulation and Compliance
Oct 28, 2021