Skip to main content

Waters Seeks GAO Study on Appraisals

Feb 19, 2020
Photo credit: Getty Images/AndreyPopov

Rep. Maxine Waters (D-CA), Chairwoman of the House Financial Services Committee, has requested the Government Accountability Office (GAO) initiate study on the implementation of Title XI of the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA) by the relevant federal agencies to determine the quality of appraisals on residential properties.
 
Waters, who was joined in her request by Rep. William Lacy Clay (D-MO), chairman of the Subcommittee on Housing, Community Development and Insurance, expressed concerns that the original Congressional intent of Title XI had been weakened by exemptions from the requirement to obtain an appraisal.
 
“Title XI was enacted by Congress in response to the numerous valuation related issues that came to light as a result of investigations and hearings into the causes of the savings and loan crisis of the mid-1980s,” the lawmakers wrote. “These appraisal regulatory provisions were enacted to help ensure the future stability of the deposit insurance fund. While Congress envisioned that most real estate related transactions would be covered by Title XI, that is no longer the case.”
 
The lawmakers also questioned whether federal regulatory increases in the appraisal threshold and the 13 regulatory “carve-outs” to reduce the number of transactions that are classified as federally regulated transactions have done more harm than good for consumers. They also raised concerns on regulations that allow the use of evaluations instead of appraisal for transactions under a specified threshold level.
 
David Bunton, president of The Appraisal Foundation, welcomed the GAO request.
 
"Thirty years ago, Congress passed FIRREA to protect homeowners and the federal deposit insurance fund from the impacts of inaccurate and inflated property valuations," said Bunton. "Over the years, however, federal agencies have created loopholes that exempt 90 percent of residential real estate transactions from the appraisal requirement."

 
About the author
Published
Feb 19, 2020
Fed Rate Could Be Down To 4.6% By Year's End

Inflation must hit its 2% goal for Fed to reduce rates.

New Compliance Requirements Add Challenges

Latest changes arrive at an already disruptive time in the mortgage industry

Changes Coming For Investment Properties

Using leases to qualify will require Proof

FCC Adopts New Rules To Close The 'Lead Generator Loophole'

Mortgage lead providers respond, saying this will "wipe out" several small and mid-tier businesses

Trade Associations & Lenders Stand Behind Trigger Leads Bill

Major trade associations like The MBA, NAMB, and BAC, urge action on S. 3502.

Supply And Demand Are Still Alive And Well

Treasury auctions may face weaker demand but they’re still getting done