Battle Cry

Proposed law could ease lending, home buying in Native American Country

Battle Cry
Associate Editor

The U.S. Department of the Interior’s Sec. 184 Indian Housing Loan Guarantee program was established by Congress in 1992 to facilitate homeownership and increase access to capital in Native American communities.

“It has been a very, very long struggle for them,” says Miki Adams, president of CBC Mortgage Agency, a firm owned by the Cedar Band of Paiute Indians of Utah, which strives to increase affordable and sustainable homeownership. 

Miki Adams
Miki Adams

She recalls the 1996 passage of the Native American Housing Assistance and Self-Determination Act, (NAHASDA) designed to provide tribes federal assistance in a manner that recognizes their right to self-governance.

“That gave them more ability to design their own housing programs that really met the needs within their own communities,” Adams says. “When you think about what it takes to own or buy a home outside of the Native American community off the reservation, you simply don’t have the bureaucracy that you do being on the reservation and having to work with another agency in order to just get title clearance.”

That bureaucracy has fostered an inequitable situation for tribal communities.

Currently, 40% of on-reservation housing is considered substandard, compared to 6% of housing outside of Indian Country. Nearly one-third of homes on reservations are overcrowded; less than half are connected to public sewer systems and 16% lack indoor plumbing altogether. “I think that federal policies have undermined the availability of adequate housing on Indian land for centuries,” Adams says. “It’s been a challenge.”

Robinson points to the cultural differences of tribal communities, rooted in the centuries-old battle they’ve fought to claim the wilderness they call home as their own. 

Miki Adams, CBC Mortgage Agency

“If you grew up in a family that owned their own home, you would grow up thinking, well, when I get older, I’m going to own my own home. I think for Native Americans who grew up on a reservation, in the past, housing was provided by the government or the tribe. You didn’t really have that culture of home ownership.”

Establishing credit - a necessary step on the path to owning a home - takes time and money. 

Also, in order to be approved for home financing on their lands, tribal authorities are required to establish statutes to govern lending. This has been another roadblock. 

Brett Robinson
Brett Robinson

Robinson headed to Washington, D.C., this fall to participate in a Sec. 184 lender summit on the statute’s underwriting guidelines.

“The guidelines haven’t been updated since 2014, so a lot has changed since then,” he said before the trip. “We’re hoping that we’ll see a lot of things that need to be addressed and hopefully some improvement.”

 

The 2023 Act The Tribal Trust Land

Homeownership Act would establish timelines for the BIA to complete mortgage processing and implement a realty ombudsman to facilitate communication between tribes, lenders, and the federal agency. 1st Tribal Lending provided insights that led to its writing.

“We’re continually working with the BIA to try to improve their processes,” Robinson says. “Our primary goal with this Act is to get a couple of centralized offices within the BIA to just focus on handling mortgage issues across the country.”

The gist of the problem, according to mortgagees who specialize in Sec. 184 lending, is that there are just too many regional land title recording offices (LTROs) and BIA outposts.

“All the documentation has to flow through all offices, and it’s just a very inefficient process,” Robinson explains. “In some areas, it works great, and in a lot of other areas, it can take months or years to get things resolved. We feel that if there were specialists within the BIA and all they did was handle preparing TSRs (Title Status Reports) and recording mortgages…it would really simplify things.”

In addition to its role as the administrative arm of tribal lending, the BIA helps facilitate down payment assistance programs like CBC Mortgage’s Chenoa Fund.

“The bureau itself has become an inefficient way for Native Americans to secure home ownership opportunities within the reservation,” Adams says. “Unfortunately, they’ve been very encumbered by their processes and by the backlog of recording title records within Indian country. We’ve heard of delays of six months, but, truthfully, the delays could be greater than that, and it’s caused some banks to not even consider lending within Indian Country.”

That’s a problem that the Tribal Trust Act seeks to solve by improving the treatment of title status reports and land title recording offices by the BIA.

Brett Robinson, 1st Tribal Lending

“The bill establishes new requirements for the processing of residential leasehold mortgages, business leasehold mortgages, land mortgages, and right-of-way documents,” Adams says. “It outlines required response times for the completion of certified title status reports, notification of delays in processing, the necessary form of notices and delivery of certain reports. Honestly, in any organization, you can’t manage what you don’t measure. So having deadlines, timeframes, and metrics for how you manage that process is necessary in order for it to work efficiently.”

The Act will also open up access to the Trust Asset and Accounting Management System (TAMS) to both lenders and tribal members. TAMS is the platform used by both the BIA and LTROs to track title records. 

“They should be able to go in and look at the status of where things are,” Adams says. “I think this provides reassurance that there’s some accountability and that things aren’t going to go into a black hole.”

This year’s legislation was introduced with bipartisan support by South Dakota Senators John Thune and Mike Rounds, as well as Sen. Tina Smith of Minnesota and Sen. Jon Tester of Montana. The Mortgage Banker Association (MBA) also issued its stamp of approval.

 

The Land

The U.S. is home to about 550 federally recognized tribes. Many are in Alaska, where a regulation prohibited the federal government from taking land in the trust up until December  2014. 

Only about 15% of 1st Tribal loans fund properties on tribal trust lands. The majority are fee simple, which denotes the maximum ownership in land that can be legally granted. 

“In order to be an approved lender in the (Sec. 184) program, you can’t just do work on fee simple properties,” Robinson says. “You have to be willing to also work on tribal trust loans. That scares away a lot of people because they just don’t have the experience or know-how to work with the BIA and to understand what’s going on behind the scenes.”

Many loan officers steer clear of tribal trust lands altogether due to the involuted process of working within the parameters. 

“Two of the most active states in the program are Alaska and Oklahoma, which have very little trust land,” Robinson adds. “They have territories and boundaries of their influence, but they weren’t actually set up as reservations.”

This history traces back to the Trail of Tears, when tribes, including the Cherokee and Chickasaw, were forcibly relocated to the frontier of the American West. 

“There are lots of Native Americans in Oklahoma because of that, but the land status is all just fee simple type transactions, which makes it a lot easier to serve them,” Robinson explains.  

When his company does a loan on tribal trust lands, it becomes a leasehold mortgage because it is based upon a lease the borrower gets from their tribe. Some staff are Natives themselves, bridging the gap to outreach. 

“All the folks who work for us are solely dedicated to Native lending and Native home ownership. They’re all very experienced in all the aspects of tribal trust lending or fee-simple with Section 184 and are uniquely suited to helping borrowers through the process. They’re doing home buyer training and things like that to get people credit and income ready.”

CBC Mortgage recently pivoted its focus to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) Farm Service Agency’s Indian Tribal Land Acquisition Loan Program.

“Their procedures are less challenging from a time standpoint; their technology has improved and they’re prepared to address and stay on top of the title issues,” Adams says. “With our recent USDA approval, we are looking to expand and be able to do more lending on reservation for our tribal members.”

 

The Lenders

There were 169 lenders on HUD’s list of Sec. 184 approved lenders as of Sept. 1. 

Loans are delivered to CBC Mortgage by correspondent-approved lenders, so they’re actually closed loan files at that point. 

“Once that loan is delivered to us, then it gets securitized into the secondary market,” Adams says. “We do actually originate loans to our tribal members ourselves so those are not delivered to us via a correspondent lender. For the most part, though, those loans have been to tribal members off reservation.”

Robinson got started in the early 2000s when he owned his own mortgage company in Santa Fe, New Mexico. That’s where he began working with Native borrowers, through national lender Greenpoint.

“When the mortgage meltdown happened, that company shut down,” he recalls. “I had a relationship with folks that worked there, about a half a dozen people, and they were really dedicated to what they did and they wanted to keep doing it and I felt like it was a great opportunity.”

The origins of 1st Tribal Lending grew from there. The company has since added a retail component and licenses in more than 40 states.

“We do about half the Section 184 business nationwide, and we have a couple-billion-dollar servicing portfolio,” Robinson says. 

HUD decreased its Sec. 184 loan guarantee fees in July of this year as a result of the program’s high success and low default rate. Advocates are still working to make it more widely available.

“We finally got HUD to open up to more counties in Texas and they also just recently added the state of Tennessee,” Robinson says. “So it’s kind of slowly happening, but there’s still a few states, mainly on the East Coast, where Section 184 is not available.”

About half of 1st Tribal Lending’s financing on tribal lands consists of construction loans, while only about 10% of those off-reservation fund new construction and renovations.

“If a Native borrower wants to buy a house, there are plenty of existing homes off tribal lands that they could buy, but if they want to live on their reservation, a lot of times the only way they can make that happen is to build a home,” Robinson says.

He calls this “the most challenging entry into homeownership” since the people who build custom homes are typically wealthier and more experienced than first-time homebuyers. 

But none of these struggles of stratification run as deep as the lack of infrastructure and housing stock that still exists on tribal lands. Even if Native homebuyer-hopefuls can get their tribe to assign a land lease to them, that parcel may not be connected to utilities. 

Like their borrowers, the lenders of Indian Country are resilient.

“It’s a challenging little niche of the mortgage business,” Robinson says. “But it’s rewarding to help and work with probably the most underserved of borrower communities in the country.” 

 

Go behind the scenes of this story on this episode of Editor's Cut.

This article was originally published in the Mortgage Banker Magazine December 2023 issue.
About the author
Associate Editor
Erica Drzewiecki is an associate editor at NMP.
Published on
Dec 05, 2023
Mortgage Banker Magazine
Feast, Then Famine

Business lost to ‘lock-in effects’ will compound for years, warns a team of FHFA economists

Ryan Kingsley
Mortgage Banker Magazine
The Big Spend

CMG Financial Starts Revving A New Engine

Ryan Kingsley
Mortgage Banker Magazine
Your Community Needs Affordable Mortgages— And So Do You

Such programs grant lenders access to referral, cash flow, and marketing opportunities

Preetam Purohit
Mortgage Banker Magazine
Ross Mortgage Corporation Celebrates 75 Years

Tim Ross talks tough decisions, TPO, and preparing to step aside

Ryan Kingsley
Mortgage Banker Magazine
The Bad Blood In Basel III

Warehouse lending could dry up if capital requirements become too burdensome

Bob Niemi
Mortgage Banker Magazine
Tradesies, Anyone?

Partnership matters more than ever to real estate agents with fewer referrals to offer

Rob Chrisman

Webinars

2025 Playbook: Learn why Credit Optimization is an Essential Tool Used by Top Lenders and Producers

With both purchase and refi activity projected to ramp up in 2025, top lenders and producers are updating thei...

Webinar
Dec 05, 2024
Investor Confidence in Today’s Non-QM And Why Originators Are Paying Attention... A Virtual Town Hall

We host Angel Oak Mortgage Solutions for a special 2021 edition of their virtual town hall series they ran fro...

Webinar
Apr 08, 2021
How to Help Real Estate Pros in a Post-Refi World

Hear from Melissa Merriman, REALTOR® with The Melissa Merriman Team at Keller Williams, on what real estate pr...

Webinar
Mar 18, 2021
Connect with your local mortgage community.

Meet your your colleagues, both national and local, by attending an event in your area.