Skip to main content

Appraiser Group Meets With Rep. Barney Frank to Discuss Fed's Rule on Appraiser Independence

Apr 19, 2011

The American Guild of Appraisers/Guild 44 of the Office and Professional Employees International Union, AFL-CIO met with Rep. Barney Frank (D-MA) to discuss the Guild's concerns with the Federal Reserve Board's Interim Final Rule (Rule) regarding Appraiser Independence. With the implementation of the Rule issued April 1, 2011, the FRB has introduced faulty regulation that implicitly fails to capture Congressional intent to reform the appraisal process and Appraiser Independence and the necessity to promote the use of market driven, Reasonable & Customary (R&C) fees for various valuation assignments. By injecting a skewed "safe harbor" under Presumption One in section 42(f), the Rule has unwittingly given license to appraisal management companies (AMCs) to use their own internal, non-market, fee schedules to disproportionately justify Reasonable and Customary fees directly in opposition to the Congressional mandate throughout the Mortgage Reform and Anti-Predatory Lending Act (MRAPLA) to have such fees excluded from Reasonable and Customary fee surveys. Guild National President Peter Vidi requested that Rep. Frank write a letter to the Federal Reserve regarding the Rule, pointing out its significant deviation from the intent of MRAPLA. "Congressional intent to restate the market survey for Customary and Reasonable Fees was not to include fees paid by appraisal management companies," said Vidi. Vidi also requested that Rep. Frank write a similar letter to Elizabeth Warren and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) stressing the need for Appraiser Independence as a means to help safeguard public interest. "Congressman Frank expressed an interest in doing so," said OPEIU Director of Organization and Field Services Kevin Kistler, "but has asked his staff to do additional research and report back to him with a recommendation before he makes a final decision as to whether to send a letter, as well as the substance of the letter." Also in attendance at the meeting was Michael Dalnekoff, treasurer of the Maryland Chapter of AGA who said, "Even with the day-to-day dealings that Congressman Frank oversees, he continues to be well versed in the appraiser section of the Dodd-Frank Act. He seemed very concerned about the information we provided."
About the author
Published
Apr 19, 2011
Moody’s Downgrades Fannie And Freddie Following U.S. Sovereign Credit Cut

Outlooks for both GSEs revised from negative to stable

May 20, 2025
A&D Mortgage Completes $427M Non-QM Securitization

Company says transaction highlights expansion in the Non-QM market, notes it expects to price more deals this year

May 19, 2025
These U.S. Metros Could Be First-Time Buyers' Best Chance To Close A Loan

Even among top 10 most affordable areas, home sale prices more than doubled in four, nearly doubled in another three since 2015

May 15, 2025
As HELOC Opportunities Grow, Angel Oak Completes Its First HELOC Securitization

$191M inaugural offering sees strong investor interest; company says it plans to package more HELOCs alongside Non-QM securitizations

May 15, 2025
DOJ Opens Criminal Investigation Into NY AG Letitia James Over Mortgage Fraud Claims

Investigation follows April referral by FHFA Director Bill Pulte; potential charges include wire, mail, and bank fraud

May 09, 2025
Origination Volume Up, But Rocket Sees GAAP Net Loss Of $212M For Q1 2025

Company highlights strength of strategic acquisitions, integrations, product innovations as it furthers its mortgage ecosystem

May 09, 2025