Florida Man Allowed to File Legal Action Against Investors in Appraisal and Origination Fraud Suit – NMP Skip to main content

Florida Man Allowed to File Legal Action Against Investors in Appraisal and Origination Fraud Suit

Oct 03, 2011

In Florida, a Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge has granted Pelayo Duran permission to include investors in his lawsuit charging Wells Fargo, Greenpoint Mortgage Funding and others with mortgage appraisal and origination fraud. This development comes days after the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), conservator of both Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, sued 17 large banks and financial institutions over losses on about $200 billion of sub-prime bonds, as well as, AIG's lawsuit against the Bank of America claiming that it lost $10 billion. "It's believed the defendants, just like in the other high-profile cases, fraudulently induced others to invest in mortgage-backed securities supported by scores of defective loans," said Duran. "Basically the defendants generated or acquired any loan, no matter how risky, that could be sold to third party investors. I was an unsuspecting victim who applied for a loan, but was duped into something else." Duran alleges in his suit that the fraud began when he tried to refinance his primary residence in 2005. He purchased the home in 2004 with an initial downpayment of $100,000. Shortly after the purchase, Duran needed to access some of the downpayment money to pay for a few personal and business obligations. Duran alleges that the Wells Fargo mortgage broker baited and switched him into a sub-prime home mortgage with Greenpoint. "She created my loan by adjusting the value of my home to my debt-to-income ratio," said Duran. "They never considered my ability to repay the loan while the hired appraiser dramatically overinflated the value. All they cared about was that appraised value and my good credit score. What I also discovered was that the Wells Fargo representative was actually originating a loan for Greenpoint Mortgage Funding. After closing my loan, Greenpoint sold it right back to Wells Fargo as trust administrator for a pool of loan." According to the lawsuit, Wells Fargo eventually placed Duran's loan in a trust called Credit Suisse First Boston Mortgage Securities Corp. Adjustable Rate Mortgage Trust 2005-5, Adjustable Rate Mortgage-Backed Pass-Through Certificates, Series 2005-5, Trust and Investors 1-1000. Duran's attorneys say it's not clear if this entity is the true holder of his note because Greenpoint has concealed the details and hasn't complied with demands to determine the rightful owner. Through a jury trial, Gonzalo R. Dorta and other members of Duran's legal team will represent Duran and hope to rescind the note and mortgage, to obtain restitution for wrongful acts, and to recover significant punitive damages.
About the author
Published
Oct 03, 2011
Closing Costs: What HUD’s Proposed Rule Will Really Do To The Market

HUD’s proposed rollback of housing protections could deepen barriers for underserved borrowers, shrink the pool of prospective homebuyers, and ultimately cost loan originators business

Aug 27, 2026
MISMO Gives Lenders A New Test For Mortgage AI Vendors

Two certifications move the industry’s FRAME initiative from governance guidance toward product-level validation and implementation

Aug 27, 2026
One Owner, Two GSEs: Would Fannie And Freddie Still Compete?

Oksenholt Capital says shared infrastructure could lower costs without weakening competition, but mortgage bankers have warned that common ownership could reduce lender choice, innovation, and market resilience

Aug 27, 2026
MaxClass: Education Meets Lead Generation

CEO Kelly Hendricks details how MaxClass and HomeQB are opening a new referral channel for originators

Fannie Mae Returns To Distressed-Loan Market With $214 Million Sale

The agency’s first nonperforming-loan offering in 13 months transfers 969 deeply delinquent mortgages to private buyers, including a small pool concentrated in Dallas-Fort Worth

Aug 20, 2026
Brief Refinance Shift Tests Mortgage Lenders’ Compliance Controls

Critical defect rate jumps 23.9% as math-based compliance findings expose the potential for one systemic error to affect loans across a lender’s book