NAMB’s strategic withdrawal of legal action against FHFA – NMP Skip to main content

NAMB’s strategic withdrawal of legal action against FHFA

National Mortgage Professional
Mar 24, 2014

NAMB’s strategic withdrawal of legal action against FHFAMortgagePress.comNAMB, HVCC, FHFA, appraisals, lawsuit, National Association of Mortgage Brokers, Federal Housing Finance Administration, Home Valuation Code of Conduct

In February 2009, the National Association of Mortgage Brokers filed suit against the Federal Housing Finance Administration (FHFA) to block implementation of the Home Valuation Code of Conduct (HVCC), which will inhibit competition among mortgage originators and increase the cost of mortgages to consumers. NAMB's suit asserted that the HVCC constituted a "de facto" rulemaking that did not comply with the requirements of the Administrative Procedures Act (APA), which sets out the procedures a federal agency must follow when issuing a regulation.

On April 2, NAMB withdrew its lawsuit against the FHFA. NAMB invoked this strategic maneuver to assess means by which we can refute the FHFA's claim that no court may review their decisions while the GSE's are in conservatorship. NAMB believes the FHFA's claim that there are no legal limits on the arbitrary and unilateral use of their conservatorship power is unprecedented and will prove detrimental to consumers.

"This issue goes beyond the bounds of this particular case," said NAMB President Marc Savitt, CRMS, "All companies, investors, and trade groups should understand there may not be a court, any court, able to hear their case while FHFA is utilizing their conservatorship powers."

NAMB strongly opposes FHFA's position that it does not need to comply with the APA and other laws. NAMB has withdrawn its lawsuit against FHFA, without prejudice, as it assesses various means to challenge FHFA's extraordinary claim. Those options include filing suit again with revised and expanded arguments directed at FHFA's new claim.

For a copy of NAMBs Lawsuit, click here.

For more information, visit

Mar 24, 2014