Court Upholds Texas Bank’s Challenge to Legality of CFPB – NMP Skip to main content

Court Upholds Texas Bank’s Challenge to Legality of CFPB

Phil Hall
Jul 24, 2015
Judges Gavel Pic

This week’ fifth anniversary observance of the Dodd-Frank Act was capped off with a surprise: The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia ruled that a Texas community bank can challenge the legality of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) and the manner in which its director, Richard Cordray, was appointed by President Obama.

In a unanimous ruling, the court determined that State National Bank of Big Spring, Texas, could bring its legal challenge against the CFPB, which was created by the Dodd-Frank Act. The Bank had argued that the CFPB’s lack of accountability to any branch of government was unconstitutional, and it also questioned whether President Obama went outside of the law using a recess appointment to put Cordray in his job while Congress was operating under a pro forma session.

The court rejected arguments by the federal government that the bank was not impacted by the CFPB and could not bring a lawsuit, noting that State National Bank’s operations fell under CFPB oversight.

"There is no doubt that the bank is regulated by the Bureau," the Court ruled. "The bank therefore has standing to challenge the constitutionality of the Bureau."

Eleven states, the 60 Plus Association and the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI) joined the bank in its campaign.

“Since Dodd-Frank’s enactment five years ago this month, the CFPB has inflicted damage on huge segments of our economy,” said Sam Kazman, CEI’s general counsel. “Its powers are so free-roaming that they are unprecedented in our history. The fact that our standing to challenge the CFPB has been upheld is great news for us, the plaintiffs, and even greater news for the American public.”

The CFPB made no public comment on the court ruling.

Published
Jul 24, 2015
MISMO Seeks Public Comment On 3 eMortgage Resources

Updates proposed to MISMO Business Glossary, eMortgage Glossary, and eModification Reference Flyer.

Regulation and Compliance
Aug 05, 2022
As Expected, The Fed Raises Rate By Another 0.75%

Experts say housing industry will shrug off the latest increase.

Regulation and Compliance
Jul 27, 2022
AmTrust Ends 'No-Poach' Agreement, Pays $1.25M Fine In Deal With N.Y. AG

Company also agrees to cooperate with ongoing investigations of the title insurance industry.

Regulation and Compliance
Jul 25, 2022
NAR Chief Economist: Nationwide Home Price Decline Won't Happen Soon

Lack of inventory continues to support growth in prices, which have increased year over year for 124 straight months.

Regulation and Compliance
Jul 22, 2022
FHFA Director: Fannie, Freddie Need $300B Combined In Capital

So far, the enterprises combined have built $83.5 billion in reserves, or about 27% of the target.

Regulation and Compliance
Jul 21, 2022
Expansion Of Community Reinvestment Act A Poor Fit For A Non-Problem

Equating non-bank mortgage companies to banks is misguided for several reasons.

Analysis and Data
Jul 20, 2022