FHFA Considers Alternative Credit as FICO Scores Tumble

Dec 21, 2017

FICO scores were in the spotlight with a regulatory agency considering credit scoring alternatives and new data highlighting a decline in FICO scores in all loan categories.

On the regulatory front, the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) issued a Request for Input (RFI) on whether to expand Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac’s credit score requirements from the current evaluation vehicles of Classic FICO, FICO 9 and VantageScore 3.0. Input to the RFI is being accepted through Feb. 20.

“In issuing this RFI, FHFA hopes to obtain honest and reliable information and stakeholder feedback on the operational and competition aspects of changing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac’s credit score requirements,” said FHFA Director Mel Watt. “Responses to the RFI will provide important details on the complexities of this decision, which is why I encourage stakeholders to respond in the most meaningful way possible.”

Separately, new data from Ellie Mae found that average FICO scores on all loans dropped to 722 in November from 724 in October. the month prior. Refinances saw FICO scores down across loan categories, with FHA refinance FICO scores dropping from 650 in October to 645 in November, conventional refinance FICO scores dipping to 730 from 732 the month prior and VA refinance FICO scores slipping to 700 from 702 in October.

“Interest rates rose slightly in November while we saw the refinance share hold at 39 percent of all closed loans,” said Jonathan Corr, President and CEO of Ellie Mae. “Additionally, we saw FICO scores drop modestly, especially across refinances, indicating that lenders may be loosening credit standards to attract the dwindling refinance market. This is certainly a trend we will continue to watch into the winter months.”

About the author

Phil Hall

Link copied

Published

Dec 21, 2017

C-Suite Strategies

Better Says It Fired Vishal Garg After He Moves To Oust Board

Founder claims majority shareholder support; company blames him for its delayed 10-Q and raises possible securities-law concerns

Better Home & Finance Holding Company said Friday that it terminated founder Vishal Garg as CEO and accused him of delaying the company’s quarterly filing, sharply escalating a dispute over control of the mortgage lender one day after Garg demanded that five directors re...

Analysis and Data

Figure Says Partners More Than Doubled HELOC Volume On Its Platform

Consumer loan marketplace volume reached $4.3 billion as Figure Connect drove more production off the company’s balance sheet and helped lift adjusted margins to a record 55%

Figure Technology Solutions said mortgage partners using its platform generated substantially more home equity lending volume than their previous production would have predicted, adding an originator-level measure to a quarter marked by rapid marketplace growth and record pr...

Sep

San Francisco, CA

More from

Industry News

July CPI Eases Mortgage-Rate Risk, But Doesn’t Promise Relief

Consumer inflation rose just 0.1% in July, reducing pressure for a September Fed rate hike as mortgage rates remain near their highest levels of the year

Industry News

Aug 13, 2026

The Fed Held. The Mortgage Market Got A Warning.

Three policymakers favored an immediate hike, while Warsh welcomed higher bond yields and offered no clear path toward mortgage-rate relief

Industry News

Jul 30, 2026

New Study Finds UWM's 'All-In' Triggered Industrywide Pricing Spillovers

Research shows wholesale competitors responded to the 2021 Rocket ban by lowering mortgage rates,

Industry News

Jul 15, 2026

First Major Housing Reform In Decades Becomes Law Without Trump's Signature

Bipartisan ROAD to Housing Act advances supply, construction, and mortgage reforms despite White House protest