Skip to main content

CFPB’s Mulvaney: No More Regulation by Enforcement

Phil Hall
Jan 24, 2018
A leaked e-mail reportedly sent by Mick Mulvaney, Acting Director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), to the staff of the agency

A leaked e-mail reportedly sent by Mick Mulvaney, Acting Director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), to the staff of the agency previewed a new and less litigious approach to regulating the financial services industry.
A leaked e-mail reportedly sent by Mick Mulvaney, Acting Director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), to the staff of the agencyIn the e-mail, which was made public via the left-wing news site ProPublica, Mulvaney cited comments made by former CFPB Director Richard Cordray that defended the agency’s reputation for “pushing the envelope” in its enforcement practices, and argued that was the worst approach for a regulator to employ.
“It is not appropriate for any government entity to ‘push the envelope’ when it comes into conflict with our citizens,” he wrote. “The damage that we can do to people could linger for years and cost them their jobs, their savings, and their homes. If the CFPB loses a court case because we ‘pushed too hard,’ we simply move on to the next matter. But where do those that we have charged go to get their time, their money, or their good names back? If a company closes its doors under the weight of a multi-year Civil Investigative Demand, you and I will still have jobs at CFPB. But what about the workers who are laid off as a result? Where do they go the next morning?”
Mulvaney made it clear that the CFPB would continue to pursue enforcement actions when and where they were appropriate, but he reversed the controversial Cordray-era approach of using enforcement to force regulations on financial institutions.
“When it comes to enforcement, we will be focusing on quantifiable and unavoidable harm to the consumer,” he continued. “If we find that it exists, you can count on us to vigorously pursue the appropriate remedies. If it doesn’t, we won’t go looking for excuses to bring lawsuits.”
Furthermore, Mulvaney addressed a long-lingering problem of the Cordray-era regarding the lack of clear communication by the CFPB on current mandates and guidelines. “On regulation, it seems that the people we regulate should have the right to know what the rules are before being charged with breaking them,” he stated. “This means more formal rulemaking on which financial institutions can rely, and less regulation by enforcement.”
Mulvaney added that the CFPB would prioritize its enforcement based on the quantity of complaints received from consumers. He noted that debt collection complaints made up nearly one-third of consumer input during 2016, while payday lending only consisted of two percent of consumer complaints. On the latter point, ProPublica ran a comment from Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), who insisted Mulvaney was going easy on payday lenders because of political donations made to him by companies in that industry.
“CFPB should protect consumers, not giant companies that use sky high interest rates to trap hundreds of thousands working Americans in debt,” she wrote, adding that the CFPB’s decision not to pursue litigation against payday lender World Acceptance Corp. was “more evidence that Mick Mulvaney is just using his time at CFPB to pay back the donors who funded his political career.”
ProPublica did not explain how it received its copy of the internal CFPB e-mail.

Jan 24, 2018
Fannie Mae Updates Underwriting To Help 'Credit Invisible' Borrowers

Enhancement to Desktop Underwriter system intended to support loans when borrower has no credit score.

Regulation and Compliance
Dec 06, 2022
MBA Offers Suggestions For Improving Refis, Forbearance

Responds to CFPB's request for information published in September.

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 30, 2022
2023 Conforming Loan Limit Tops $1M For High-Cost Areas

FHFA said the baseline conforming loan limit will increase 12% next year.

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 29, 2022
FHA Extends Waivers To Its HECM Loss-Mitigation Policies 

Extension applies to senior borrowers affected by COVID-19.

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 28, 2022
N.J. Real Estate Developer, Lawyer Admit To Mortgage Fraud

Plead guilty to defrauding Fannie Mae, insurers of over $3.5 million.

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 28, 2022
Strength In Numbers

Seeking advice from the CFPB

Regulation and Compliance
Nov 21, 2022