Appeals Court Upholds CFPB Constitutionality

Jan 31, 2018

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit has ruled in an 8-3 judgment that the single director leadership structure of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) does not violate the Constitution, overturning an earlier court ruling that stated the opposite. The court also ruled ruled that a president can only remove the CFPB Director from office for cause and not at will.

“Applying binding Supreme Court precedent, we see no constitutional defect in the statute preventing the president from firing the CFPB director without cause,” Judge Nina Pillard wrote for the court. “We thus uphold Congress’s choice. Congress’s decision to provide the CFPB Director a degree of insulation reflects its permissible judgment that civil regulation of consumer financial protection should be kept one step removed from political winds and presidential will. We have no warrant here to invalidate such a time-tested course.”

The court’s ruling, in the case PHH Corp. v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, noted that the CFPB director can only be fired for “inefficiency, neglect of duty, or malfeasance in office.”

The case will likely be appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court by the Trump Administration, which has cited the CFPB’s unaccountability to the executive and legislative branches of government.

About the author

Phil Hall

Link copied

Published

Jan 31, 2018

Wholesale

NEXA Removes The Guardrails From Its 100% Revenue Model

NEXA Unlimited drops key production and recruiting requirements as Mike Kortas bets the brokerage’s growing scale can support 100% revenue economics

NEXA Lending is removing some of the barriers around its 100% revenue model, allowing loan originators to access the economics without meeting production or recruiting requirements on loans through select lenders.The brokerage announced NEXA Unlimited Tuesday, saying loan or...

People On The Move

Rocket Taps Meta Executive Alessio Sanfilippo To Lead Redfin

Former Intuit executive succeeds interim CEO Varun Krishna as Rocket pushes deeper integration across home search, brokerage, mortgage, closing, and servicing

Rocket Companies has named former Meta and Intuit executive Alessio Sanfilippo chief executive officer of Redfin, placing a product, data, and artificial intelligence veteran in charge of the real estate brokerage as Rocket works to connect more of the homebuying process wit...

Sep

San Francisco, CA

More from

Regulation and Compliance

Closing Costs: What HUD’s Proposed Rule Will Really Do To The Market

HUD’s proposed rollback of housing protections could deepen barriers for underserved borrowers, shrink the pool of prospective homebuyers, and ultimately cost loan originators business

Opinion

Aug 27, 2026

MISMO Gives Lenders A New Test For Mortgage AI Vendors

Two certifications move the industry’s FRAME initiative from governance guidance toward product-level validation and implementation

Tech

Aug 27, 2026

One Owner, Two GSEs: Would Fannie And Freddie Still Compete?

Oksenholt Capital says shared infrastructure could lower costs without weakening competition, but mortgage bankers have warned that common ownership could reduce lender choice, innovation, and market resilience

Analysis and Data

Aug 27, 2026

MaxClass: Education Meets Lead Generation

CEO Kelly Hendricks details how MaxClass and HomeQB are opening a new referral channel for originators

Regulation and Compliance

Aug 20, 2026

Fannie Mae Returns To Distressed-Loan Market With $214 Million Sale

The agency’s first nonperforming-loan offering in 13 months transfers 969 deeply delinquent mortgages to private buyers, including a small pool concentrated in Dallas-Fort Worth

Analysis and Data

Aug 20, 2026

Brief Refinance Shift Tests Mortgage Lenders’ Compliance Controls

Critical defect rate jumps 23.9% as math-based compliance findings expose the potential for one systemic error to affect loans across a lender’s book

Regulation and Compliance

Aug 20, 2026

Popular