Moody’s Warns Appraisal Alternatives Create RMBS Risks

Feb 21, 2018

The increased use of alternatives to traditional residential property appraisals has the potential to dilute the credit quality of new residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS) unless certain risks are mitigated, according to a new report from Moody’s Investors Service.

In its report, Moody’s warns that appraisal alternatives including hybrid appraisals, broker price opinions and automated valuation models take varying approaches to determining property values and, as a result, could present the potential for inconsistent results that could prove disruptive in the securitization process.

“In seeking to reduce operational costs, increase efficiencies and address the shrinking ranks of U.S. property appraisers, mortgage market participants are exploring the use of alternatives to traditional means of calculating property values and, in some cases, starting to use them more,” said Lima Ekram, a Moody’s Analyst. “Their use in tasks that affect the credit quality of RMBS securitization collateral could, however, lead to a weakening of new RMBS transactions.”

However, Moody’s noted that there are some cases where alternatives could potentially improve the credit quality of RMBS transactions, adding in its report that “decisions to deploy cheaper valuation options, for example, could help preempt a shift toward smaller sampling during quality control or due diligence.”

About the author

Phil Hall

Link copied

Published

Feb 21, 2018

Regulation and Compliance

Mortgage AI Survey Finds Monitoring Gap At Smaller Lenders

Only 40% of smaller lenders surveyed reported ongoing AI monitoring, compared with 80% of larger lenders, as a new state examiner guide details the records regulators may request

Mortgage companies have been putting AI policies in place. Keeping watch over the tools after they go live is proving less consistent, particularly among smaller lenders.A new survey by the American Association of Residential Mortgage Regulators (AARMR), the Mortgage Bankers...

Operations

Can AI Crack The Mortgage Approval Gap?

A company white paper links lower decline rates to its AI-enabled workflow, then estimates the potential lending volume if those rates held nationwide.

Mortgage applications processed through AngelAi at Sun West Mortgage had substantially lower decline rates in 2025 than applications in the national market, according to a new company white paper. The gap appeared across Asian, Black, Hispanic, and white applicant groups.Sun...

Nov

Pasadena, CA

More from

Industry News

Rocket Makes VantageScore Its Default After Testing Finds Borrower Savings

After four months of testing, Rocket will make VantageScore 4.0 its preferred model for eligible retail loans while keeping both scoring options available to brokers

Industry News

Sep 29, 2026

CHLA: More Freddie Mac MBS Buying Could Narrow Mortgage Spreads

Trade group estimates greater Freddie participation could compress spreads another 10 to 12 basis points as Fannie has taken the lead in GSE mortgage-bond buying

Industry News

Sep 23, 2026

Early Loan-Limit Race Splits Into Three Tiers

Lenders are now offering $845,000, $847,440, or $850,000 before FHFA sets the official 2027 limits

Industry News

Sep 23, 2026

Better, Garg Clash Over Claimed 46% Shareholder Support

Better disputes its former CEO’s preliminary consent count as the two sides trade accusations and an Oct. 2 target date approaches

C-Suite Strategies

Sep 23, 2026

Fannie Changes How Rent From A Former Home Counts

Fannie now prohibits leases for departing residences and permits market-analysis tools instead of Form 1007, creating a key documentation difference from Freddie Mac

Regulation and Compliance

Sep 22, 2026