The Most Affordable Metro for Middle-Class Families Is … – NMP Skip to main content

The Most Affordable Metro for Middle-Class Families Is …

Aug 20, 2019
Photo credit: Getty Images/TracieMichelle

A middle-class family in the Detroit metro area would only need to earn $26,690 per year to purchase a home at the area's median price point, according to a new data analysis by Redfin, which noted that sum is less than half of the area's $56,339 median income, making it the most affordable metro in the nation.
 
Other affordable metro areas for middle-class families include the western New York markets of Rochester and Buffalo plus Dayton, Ohio, where families need to earn about $30,000 annually–roughly about half of each area's median household income–to buy the typical home. Rounding out the top five is Pittsburgh, where households need to earn just over $30,000–also much less than the area's median income–to buy a median-priced home.
 
At the other end of the spectrum, San Francisco was ranked least affordable. In that market, the median household income of $92,714 falls far wildly short of the $265,000 per year needed to afford a median-priced home, which costs $1.42 million. The other five least affordable metros are all in California: Anaheim, San Jose, Los Angeles and San Diego.
 
“People who live in places like Detroit, Pittsburgh and Cleveland tend to earn lower salaries than people in expensive coastal areas, but in many ways, the Midwesterners' quality of life is better,” said Redfin Chief Economist Daryl Fairweather. “Even though they may make less money, it's easier to purchase a home and build equity while providing for a family. It's no secret there's an affordability crisis in high-priced places like the Bay Area, where modest homes can sell for well over $1 million. But in most of the country, homes are still affordable on the typical local income. That's one reason people are looking to move to places like Phoenix, Atlanta and Las Vegas, where homes are affordable on realistic incomes.”

 
About the author
Published
Aug 20, 2019
Trump Taps Former CFPB Deputy Brian Johnson To Lead Bureau

MBA backs the nomination as lenders await clarity on the future direction of consumer finance regulation under the Trump administration

Jun 12, 2026
Trump Names FHFA Director Bill Pulte Acting Director Of National Intelligence

FHFA director will continue overseeing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac while serving as acting director of national intelligence

Jun 02, 2026
Realtor.com Launches AI Home Search Platform Built With Google

New RealAssist tool combines AI, affordability guidance and Google Maps data to engage buyers before they reach lenders

Jun 02, 2026
Another MLS Challenges Zillow In Fight Over Listing Visibility

Realtracs joins MRED in pushing back on Zillow's listing policies, a battle with potential implications for the broader homebuying and mortgage ecosystem

May 29, 2026
Gas Prices Are Quietly Reshaping Homebuyer Affordability

Rocket Money data suggests rising fuel costs are adding pressure to already payment-sensitive buyers as mortgage rates remain elevated

May 28, 2026
MISMO Targets Costly TRID Fee Cures With New Mortgage Fee Standardization Framework

MBA’s standards organization says inconsistent fee naming still drives costly redisclosures and rework, with fee-related cures affecting more than 30% of mortgage loans

May 27, 2026