Skip to main content

Most Homeowners Underestimate Hurricane-Related Damage Costs

Aug 21, 2019
Photo credit: Getty Images/ChamilleWhite

This year’s hurricane season is now underway through November, and while there are no storms on the near-term horizon that should raise red flags, a new study by ValuePenguin.com found many homeowners in high-risk states expressed either ignorance or nonchalance regarding the property damage costs of hurricanes.
 
In a survey of 1,050 homeowners in hurricane-prone states, 77 percent of respondents said they "felt prepared" for the 2019 hurricane season, although about 48 percent of the same respondents admitted they never began to make preparations. Meteorological warnings are ignored by many: 43 percent of respondents who live in high-risk states believed weather forecasting professionals exaggerate the risk of hurricanes.
 
When evacuation warnings are made, 56 percent of the surveyed homeowners said they were reluctant to evacuate their homes and would comply to mandatory orders to leave. One in 10 said they would not evacuate at all, despite orders to leave.
 
As for the costs of hurricane-related damages, 52 percent of the surveyed homeowners guessed that they would spend less than $10,000 repairing their homes after a hurricane. In reality, the average claim amounts in 2017 for wind and hail damage were $10,200 while flooding damage averaged $92,000. And in the markets where hurricane risk is highest, 45 percent of respondents said they didn't know how much insurance coverage they would need to be fully protected.
 
“As the peak of the 2019 hurricane season approaches, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration updated its forecast to predict five to nine hurricanes in the Atlantic before the end of November,” said Chris Moon, Senior Research Analyst at Value Penguin.com. “Most hurricane seasons to date have included six. Yet in our survey, nearly half of all respondents predicted that the United States would experience no more than three hurricanes in 2019.”
 
In May, CoreLogic estimated that more than 7.3 million single and multifamily homes along the Gulf and Atlantic Coasts face the potential for storm surge damage during this year’s Atlantic hurricane season. Florida has the most exposure to storm surge flooding, with more than 2.9 million homes at risk and the potential for more than $603 billion in replacement cost value (RCV), while Louisiana has the second most exposure to storm surge flooding with more than 847,000 at-risk homes an RCV at over $202 billion. New York third in the number of homes at risk with more than over 564,000 in the potential for harm’s way plus more than $240 billion in RCV costs.

 
About the author
Published
Aug 21, 2019
CoreLogic Chief Economist On Witnessing The Insurance Crisis Firsthand

"I could have lost all my equity,” says Selma Hepp, who lives and works on the frontline of housing's biggest challenge in 2025

Jan 20, 2025
Bill Pulte Trump’s Pick For FHFA Director

The founder and CEO of private equity firm, Pulte Capital Partners, LLC, will oversee plans to end GSE conservatorship

Jan 17, 2025
How To Help Borrowers Spot Red Flags Of Mortgage Fraud

Nine years after a foreclosure relief scam unfolded, the FTC is releasing seized funds. Lessons for LOs abound in how it all went down.

L.A. Wildfires Worsen California Insurance Crisis

Home insurers nowhere to be found during "one of the worst wildfire incidents on record”

Jan 13, 2025
FHFA Director Sandra Thompson To Resign On Eve Of Trump Inauguration

Thompson’s departure clears the way for Trump appointee to take over

Jan 10, 2025
CFPB Accuses Experian Of 'Sham' Consumer Dispute Investigations

The alleged conduct results in errors remaining on consumer reports, and errors being reinserted even after resolution

Jan 07, 2025