Casa Issues Mea Culpa; Takes Leave As AIME Chair – NMP Skip to main content

Casa Issues Mea Culpa; Takes Leave As AIME Chair

Jul 17, 2020
Anthony Casa AIME
Senior Editor

Anthony Casa, the embattled chairman of the Association of Independent Mortgage Experts, is taking a leave of absence from his role. It comes in the wake of lewd and sexist videos he sent about a mortgage executive's wife; actions which he now calls “inexcusable.”
 
In his announcement, Casa apologizes to Theresa Niemiec and her family. She is the wife of Austin Niemic, executive vice president of Quicken Loans.
 
No mention is made of how long Casa’s leave will be. His decision comes after Plaza Home Mortgage, Flagstar Bank and Caliber Home Loans each announced that they are suspending their relationships with AIME due to Casa’s comments, according to HousingWire. 
 
The California Association of Mortgage Professionals issued a statement saying more needs to be done besides talks and leaves of absence. "This quote best reflects our position 'We’re not accepting verbal apologies this year, just changed behavior.'" The group added, "We challenge the mortgage industry to not just say they are outraged but to take steps to ensure that everyone in the profession is held to a higher standard and that bullies are removed from positions of power and leadership."
 
Casa sent Austin Niemic videos, which contain crude and misogynistic language, claiming Theresa Niemic performed sexual acts on Mat Ishbia, United Wholesale Mortgage president and CEO, while in college. Theresa Niemic and Ishbia did not attend college together and she is significantly younger than him.
 
Theresa Niemic sued Casa because he would not take the videos down after receiving a request from her attorneys. Casa instead sent mocking texts to Austin Niemic loaded with sexually suggestive emojis.
 
Casa's first response to the issue came about a week after the cease-and-desist demand when it became known a story was being published about the videos. In an eight-minute message on his Facebook page, which appears to have been taken down. Casa called his videos and texts, “an error in judgment” and “a big mistake.” He described himself as “too vested” in the broker movement and said it has to do with “being from New Jersey” as well as being vocal and competitive.
 
Casa said Austin Niemic initiated the hostile exchange with a text message of the couple celebrating “a record month or record quarter” at Quicken.  Austin Niemic issued his own response denying he initiated the conversation and said instead it was Casa who commenced it.
 
AIME said in its statement the association will be managed in Casa’s absence by president Marc Summers and Katie Sweeney, executive vice president of strategy.
About the author
Senior Editor
Keith Griffin is a senior editor at NMP.
Published
Jul 17, 2020
CHLA: More Freddie Mac MBS Buying Could Narrow Mortgage Spreads

Trade group estimates greater Freddie participation could compress spreads another 10 to 12 basis points as Fannie has taken the lead in GSE mortgage-bond buying

Sep 23, 2026
Early Loan-Limit Race Splits Into Three Tiers

Lenders are now offering $845,000, $847,440, or $850,000 before FHFA sets the official 2027 limits

Sep 23, 2026
Better, Garg Clash Over Claimed 46% Shareholder Support

Better disputes its former CEO’s preliminary consent count as the two sides trade accusations and an Oct. 2 target date approaches

Sep 23, 2026
Fannie Changes How Rent From A Former Home Counts

Fannie now prohibits leases for departing residences and permits market-analysis tools instead of Form 1007, creating a key documentation difference from Freddie Mac

MPF Expands Eligibility For Manufactured And Renovation Loans

The Mortgage Partnership Finance Program has expanded MPF Traditional eligibility for affordable loans, manufactured homes, renovations, and lender-funded assistance

Sep 22, 2026
Fed Hike Raises HELOC Costs While Mortgage Rates Stay Near 7%

Prime rose to 7% while the 10-year Treasury remained near 5%, giving originators two different borrower conversations

Sep 17, 2026