Abandoning Tri-Merge Could Raise Borrowing Costs And Investor Risk – NMP Skip to main content

Abandoning Tri-Merge Could Raise Borrowing Costs And Investor Risk

Feb 24, 2026
Abandoning Tri-Merge Could Increase Costs And Risks

A new analysis finds that replacing the tri-merge credit reporting standard could reduce risk assessment accuracy, ultimately driving higher mortgage rates, tighter credit access, and increased uncertainty for borrowers and investors

New research from Andrew Davidson & Company warns that moving away from the long-standing tri-merge credit reporting standard in mortgage underwriting could significantly increase borrowing costs and introduce new risks for consumers and investors.

The tri-merge system — which combines credit data from the three major credit bureaus — has historically provided lenders and mortgage investors with a comprehensive and reliable view of borrower creditworthiness. The firm’s analysis found that replacing this approach with single-bureau reporting or alternative credit models could reduce the accuracy of credit risk assessments, leading to unintended consequences across the mortgage ecosystem.

According to the research, weaker credit visibility would likely force lenders and investors to price in greater uncertainty, resulting in higher mortgage rates for borrowers overall. Even small increases in perceived risk can translate into meaningful pricing adjustments, particularly in secondary markets where mortgage-backed securities depend heavily on consistent and predictable credit performance.

The study also highlighted potential downstream effects for mortgage investors, including increased credit losses and reduced confidence in loan performance. These changes could lead to tighter underwriting standards or reduced liquidity in certain loan segments, limiting access to credit for marginal borrowers. Over time, the cumulative impact could shift costs onto consumers through higher rates, stricter qualification requirements, or both.

"We are going through a modernization phase in the mortgage industry," said Sanjeeban Chatterjee, director of behavioral modeling at Andrew Davidson & Company. "At such times, it is important to understand the impact of the changes so that the stakeholders can make the right decisions. This study shows why knowing more is better from a risk management and affordability perspective."

Andrew Davidson & Company emphasized that the tri-merge framework has played a central role in supporting investor confidence and maintaining standardized risk evaluation across the mortgage industry. By providing a more complete borrower profile, the system helps ensure that mortgage pricing accurately reflects risk without introducing unnecessary volatility or uncertainty.

The findings arrive as policymakers and housing finance stakeholders explore potential reforms aimed at reducing costs and modernizing credit reporting. However, the research cautions that changes intended to streamline underwriting could have the opposite effect if they weaken the reliability of credit assessment tools.

About the author
Published
Feb 24, 2026
Existing-Home Sales Hit 16-Year Low, More Declines May Be Ahead

October sales plunged 5.5% as high mortgage rates sidelined buyers, with economists warning the slowdown could extend into November and December closings

Nov 13, 2026
Income Calculation Errors Drive Mortgage Quality Concerns

An ACES Quality Management report finds that critical mortgage defects declined in the second quarter, even as income calculation errors, borrower eligibility issues, and appraisal findings increased

Nov 12, 2026
Even at 6%, Mortgage Rates May Not Be Enough to Unlock Home Sales

New Realtor.com analysis finds that moving would still increase the typical homeowner's mortgage payment by nearly 62%

Nov 11, 2026
Younger Borrowers Want More Personal Guidance Despite Digital Gains

Nearly half say their lender representative should have been more involved, while fewer borrowers overall receive same-day answers, JD Power finds

Nov 10, 2026
Mortgage Locks Plunge 19% Despite Rate Relief, ARM Share Hits New High

October's sharp decline in lending activity points to a tougher purchase market, even as borrowers turn to ARMs, FHA, and Non-QM financing

Nov 10, 2026
Condo Sellers Outnumber Buyers 2 to 1 as Financing Pressures Mount

Redfin reports the widest condo market imbalance in 13 years, giving buyers more negotiating power

Nov 10, 2026