Another Home Insurance Crisis Brewing? – NMP Skip to main content

Another Home Insurance Crisis Brewing?

Jul 07, 2025
Homeowners Delaying Major Repairs
ChatGPT / OpenAI
Staff Writer

Homeowners delaying major repair work — or doing the work themselves instead of hiring professional tradesmen

Homeowners are either postponing important maintenance on their properties or doing the work themselves, all because it is too expensive to do otherwise, according to a new survey of 1,000 owners.

The delays are quietly putting their homes and their values in danger, perhaps ushering in a new era of risk. Guardian Service, a company that helps homeowners shop for insurance coverage, calls it a “silent insurance crisis.”

The survey found: 

  • Nearly three out of every four owners polled are putting off renovations or repairs because of economic uncertainty; 
  • Nearly a third said they were willing to wait another two years if necessary to make major upgrades to things like leaky roofs and outdated electrical systems; and 
  • About one in eight are deferring such projects indefinitely. 

Home improvement budgets have been sliced, too, the pollsters found — on average by 42%. And when it comes to saving money, nearly two-thirds of homeowner respondents said they did the work themselves rather than hiring an expensive professional tradesman.

“DIY fixes aren’t a sign of resilience,” Guardian Services’ Kara Credle told National Mortgage Professional. “They’re a warning sign. With 62% of homeowners tackling critical repairs themselves, not by choice but necessity, it’s clear financial pressure is forcing risky workarounds that could cost more down the line.” 

Another revealing finding: Nearly one in four homeowners admitted they’ve avoided filing an insurance claim because they were afraid their home’s condition might trigger an inspection or even a denial — or worse, higher insurance premiums.

Yet, one in five respondents said they were not aware that putting off repairs could negatively impact their property’s value or insurability. But for some, the consequences are already hitting home: some 13% said they’ve had trouble renewing their coverage, while 11% were charged higher premiums because of damage or outdated features.

“The rising cost of living is affecting more than groceries and gas. It’s also impacting how Americans care for their homes,” Guardian Services’ report states. “With the majority delaying needed upgrades, and many unaware of the insurance implications, households may be risking more than they realize.”

Here, a little knowledge would go a long way, the company says. People need to know that some improvements like a new roof or safety-focused upgrades could actually lower their premiums, thereby reducing overall costs.

About the author
Staff Writer
Lew Sichelman has been covering the housing and mortgage sectors for 52 years. His syndicated column appears in major newspapers throughout the country.
Published
Jul 07, 2025
Higher Mortgage Rates Shrink Purchase Demand, Expand Buyer Leverage

Pending sales fell to their lowest level since early April, but lower asking prices and reduced competition give originators more options to structure deals for qualified borrowers

Jul 31, 2026
Even Stable Public-Service Careers No Longer Guarantee Homeownership

Younger teachers, health care workers, first responders, and military households can afford median-priced homes in only a fraction of major metros

Jul 31, 2026
Buyers Gain Negotiating Power In 41 Major Housing Markets

Price cuts and longer listing times are creating opportunities for loan officers to help borrowers negotiate seller concessions, but leverage varies sharply by metro

Jul 30, 2026
Fannie Mae Purchase Volume Jumps 33% In Second Quarter

The GSE financed 201,000 home purchases, while appraisal alternatives pushed estimated borrower closing-cost savings to $3 billion

Jul 29, 2026
Second-Home Lending Grows Faster Than Primary-Home Market

Vacation-home mortgages rose 4.1% in 2025, led overwhelmingly by affluent borrowers

Jul 28, 2026
Credit Score Battle Picks Up Speed With FICO, VantageScore Gains

FICO 10T enrollment tops 70 lenders while VantageScore 4.0’s presence in TransUnion mortgage credit pulls jumps from less than 5% to roughly 30%

Jul 28, 2026