Attorney Opinions Don’t Count

Title waiver pilot, unregulated title alternatives a risky game for lenders and taxpayers

Attorney Opinions Don’t Count
Founder and Managing Member

The title industry isn’t alone in voicing concern about the pilot. Ed DeMarco, who was acting director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA) during the Obama Administration and now heads the Housing Policy Council trade group, in a letter to the FHFA implored the agency to “approach this issue with caution and a sensitivity to the role title insurers and title insurance plays in lowering risk for lenders and consumers alike.” U.S. Reps. Andrew Garbarino, Bill Huizenga, and Warren Davidson wrote in a letter to the FHFA that a change like this “requires rigorous scrutiny.” Additionally, 18 House Democrats recently signed a letter to President Biden stating, “ … allowing the GSEs to assume unnecessary risk outside their core mission, possibly violating their charters, is not the path we should take.”

Title insurance is necessary for refinance transactions

On a refinance, lenders require title insurance to ensure the new loan is protected. If not done correctly, a lender could risk not having lien priority. Risk of fraud is another reason why lenders need title insurance on a refinance. After a couple purchased a home, the husband attempts to refinance and take his wife off the title and mortgage ahead of a pending divorce. The lender would be protected from any claims made by the wife down the road. Additional examples of title claims on lender’s policies include the failure of a prior lender to properly close a HELOC after settlement, boundary line disputes, and invalid mortgages because documents were executed with an improper power of attorney.

The title industry has a lower claims rate than other lines of insurance because of the curative work title professionals perform. Preventing claims is the title industry’s goal. It’s why 70 cents of every dollar in premium the industry collects are spent acquiring and analyzing public real estate records data. Further, while rates for other forms of insurance have increased in recent years, the cost of title insurance coverage has decreased 7.8% since 2004, based on recent industry financial statements.

Title insurance is a well-known, established step in the homebuying process and is regulated by state insurance and consumer protection regulators. AOLs don’t have similar oversight. Title insurance companies must maintain financial reserves to cover future claims risks. AOL providers do not. Additionally, AOLs typically do not provide an unlimited duty to defend the policyholder in the event of a claim, leaving homeowners open to future financial burden.

Despite being promoted as a cost-savings over title insurance, AOLs can be more expensive for homebuyers, while at the same time exposing them to more risk. In most states, the seller pays for the homebuyer’s title insurance policy. This means homebuyers only pay a reduced fee for the lender’s policy at closing. This often can cost the homebuyer as little as $150. When combined with other discounts, title insurance is not only less expensive, but more protective, than AOLs.

Title waiver pilot risky game

Policymakers have concerns about the title waiver pilot and AOLs

When the FHFA considered this pilot concept last year, several members of Congress from both sides of the aisle asked FHFA Director Sandra Thompson about it during a House Financial Services Committee hearing. The legislators expressed concerns that Fannie Mae would be expanding outside their charter by operating in a primary market business with this pilot program. Additionally, U.S. Reps. Young Kim (R-CA) and Brad Sherman (D-CA) sent a letter on Feb. 27 to the FHFA sharing concerns over the promotion of unregulated AOLs in place of title insurance.

These risks are why Reps. Andrew Garbarino (R-NY) and Vicente Gonzalez (D-TX) have introduced the bipartisan Protecting America’s Property Rights Act to require title insurance from a state-licensed title insurance company on all loans purchased by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. Garbarino called the Administration’s pilot proposal “a misguided reversal of a decision made by FHFA and Fannie Mae last year after bipartisan disapproval.”

Without understanding the full extent of risks that are associated with the title waiver pilot and AOLs, lenders may find their lien priority in jeopardy while consumers may face increased threats to their ownership rights. When it comes to one of life’s greatest investments, lenders and consumers should protect that investment the absolute best way they can — with the proven security of title insurance.

This article originally appeared in National Mortgage Professional, on the week of June 1, 2024.
About the author
Founder and Managing Member
Deborah Bailey Esq. is the Founder and Managing Member of Bailey Helms Legal LLC, a boutique transactional real property law firm in Roswell, GA. Bailey also serves as a member of the American Land Title Association’s Board of…
Published on
Jun 03, 2024
More from NMP Magazine
NMP
VA Home Loans: Veterans Deserve Better Information, Better Experiences

Despite widespread awareness of VA home loans, misconceptions about down payments and interest rates persist, putting greater responsibility on lenders to educate veteran borrowers

Pat Schlimmer
NMP
NMP's 2026 Best Military Lenders

National Mortgage Professional’s Best Military Lenders award honors the companies that go above and beyond for active-duty military members, veterans, reservists, and their families.

National Mortgage Professional
NMP
NMP's 2026 Best Military Originators

Every year, NMP sets out to find the originators who do far more than close VA loans. This year’s 10 honorees have turned military lending into a calling.

National Mortgage Professional
NMP
The Cost of Keeping America Building

With buyers struggling to afford homes and construction costs squeezing margins, builders are turning to private capital, aggressive incentives, and new technology to keep projects moving. But how long can those strategies hold?

Czarinna Andres
NMP
Appraisal Fees Under Fire

Appraisers face stagnant pay and rising costs as AMCs defend their fees and new technology reshapes the industry

Czarinna Andres
NMP
The Hidden Cost Of Appraisal Uncertainty

As home equity lending grows, lenders need a better way to resolve conflicting property evidence before it creates costly setbacks

Gerald M. Green

Webinars

AI Digital Assets Are Here: Is Your Mortgage Business Ready?

Explore how artificial intelligence, blockchain technology, and digital assets are shaping the future of mortg...

Webinar
Nov 10, 2026
Investor Confidence in Today’s Non-QM And Why Originators Are Paying Attention... A Virtual Town Hall

We host Angel Oak Mortgage Solutions for a special 2021 edition of their virtual town hall series they ran fro...

Webinar
Apr 08, 2021
How to Help Real Estate Pros in a Post-Refi World

Hear from Melissa Merriman, REALTOR® with The Melissa Merriman Team at Keller Williams, on what real estate pr...

Webinar
Mar 18, 2021
Connect with your local mortgage community.

Meet your your colleagues, both national and local, by attending an event in your area.