First-Time Homebuyer VS. Repeat Homebuyer Fears – NMP Skip to main content

First-Time Homebuyer VS. Repeat Homebuyer Fears

Oct 29, 2021
Black and white photo of a woman looking nervous and scared.
Director of Events

Both first-time and repeat homebuyers have their fair share of fears as they navigate the process, however, these fears aren't alike.

KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • 40.4% of first-time homebuyers in the study are afraid there might be better options out there than the homes they are looking at.
  • 36.8% of first-time homebuyers are afraid of not being able to afford their mortgage.
  • 41.6% of repeat homebuyers are afraid of rising home prices.
  • 41.6% of repeat homebuyers are afraid that inventory will continue to decline.

A recent study from Ojo Labs took a look at the different fears that first-time and repeat homebuyers have. Both sides are afraid of the homebuying process, though the fears they ranked the highest and ones that affect the process differ, according to Patrick Kearns, director of storytelling for Ojo Labs.

“A survey of 200 homebuyers conducted between July 2020 and July 2021 found that, on average, buyers reported a fear level of 51.2 on a scale from 0-100,” according to the report. “First-time buyers skewed slightly higher on that same scale, reporting a fear level of 52.9, while repeat buyers reported a fear level of 50.7.”

First-time homebuyers have more financial-related fears than their repeating counterparts. They mostly feared not being able to afford a mortgage and taking a look at their own finances, according to the report. 

“Despite financial-related fears dominating the top five, it was actually the fear that there are better options out there that was the top-rated fear for first-time homebuyers,” according to Kearns. 

Meanwhile, the top fears for repeat homebuyers fall under continuously rising home prices and an inventory shortage that is continuing to trouble the housing industry and driving up competition among buyers who are desperate to find a home. 

“Repeat buyers let their top fears have a bigger impact on their timelines, however, with a fear of rising home prices delaying their timeline by an average 11.1 days,” said Kearns in his report. “A fear that inventory would continue to decline delayed timelines, while a fear that there would be better options out there delayed timelines by 28.5 days, nearly a month—a stark contrast from first-time homebuyers.”

About the author
Director of Events
Navi Persaud is Director of Events at NMP.
Published
Oct 29, 2021
More Buyers Expect Higher Rates. Fewer Would Wait.

Veterans United’s survey finds less willingness to hold out for lower rates, but little change in purchase timelines

Oct 22, 2026
Mortgage Rate Lock-In: More High-Rate Loans, Few Signs Of A Thaw

With 30-year rates above 7% and nearly half of outstanding loans below 4%, originators face a stubborn obstacle to rebuilding repeat-buyer pipelines

Oct 22, 2026
Investor Homebuying Slows, Small Buyers Claim Biggest Share In 15 Years

Smaller investors accounted for 66.2% of investor purchases in the first half of 2026 and relied on cash much less often than mega-investors

Oct 22, 2026
California Home Sales Drop 6.5%, Prices Keep Climbing

September’s decline leaves originators competing for fewer purchases, while rising borrowing costs and limited new listings keep affordability under pressure

Oct 20, 2026
One In Three Americans Blame Lenders For Housing Crisis Ahead Of Midterms

Voters want lower taxes, insurance costs, and mortgage rates, but 63% doubt the election will improve housing

Oct 20, 2026
Rates Above 7% Shrink Buyer Budgets In Loosening Housing Market

Realtor.com finds 66 of 99 metros favor buyers or are moving that way, while rising financing costs have cut borrowing capacity 7.2% since late August for a fixed monthly payment

Oct 19, 2026