Half Of Prospective Homebuyers Cannot Afford Basic Home Costs – NMP Skip to main content

Half Of Prospective Homebuyers Cannot Afford Basic Home Costs

Sep 05, 2024
unaffordable
Associate Editor

Home insurance costs are becoming a driving factor for relocation

A new survey reveals that nearly 50% of prospective home buyers are grappling with the affordability of basic home costs, with home insurance emerging as a significant factor influencing their relocation decisions. The survey of 1,818 U.S. adults, conducted by Mphasis Digital Risk, a mortgage and financial services company, highlights the impact of rising home-related expenses on the housing market.

Despite concerns about housing costs and insurance premiums, Americans show a more optimistic outlook on mortgage rates. Over 40% identify a 5% interest rate as their ideal "magic number" for making a home purchase, with 27% favoring 4% and 20% targeting 6%. Additionally, 64% of respondents are either "very encouraged" (21%) or "somewhat encouraged" (43%) about the prospect of falling mortgage rates in the near future.

However, the survey also indicates that 40% of potential buyers are postponing their home purchases until after November's presidential election. Among the concerns driving this delay, 30% attribute high mortgage rates to inflation, while 23% blame the current administration and 13%, the Federal Reserve.

A striking 48% of participants reported difficulties with home-related expenses, including maintenance, utilities, taxes, and insurance. Nearly 40% have experienced a significant increase in monthly payments, prompting over 25% to seek payment plans. Furthermore, 47% cited home insurance costs as a major factor in their decision to move, with 25% considering relocation due to extreme weather and 26% knowing someone who has moved for similar reasons.

"While inflation pushed mortgage rates to a peak of 8% in October 2023, rates have since decreased by over 1.5%,” remarked Jeff Taylor, co-founder and managing director of Mphasis Digital Risk, remarked. "As we approach more favorable rates in the low-6% to high-5% range, and with anticipated Fed cuts in September, buyer sentiment is improving. This positions us for a strong 2025, with projected mortgage originations reaching $2 trillion."

Nearly 30% of survey respondents are eyeing home purchases in the latter half of the year, but many are feeling the pressures of a seller's market. Over 20% have been searching for more than two years, with 17% expressing frustration and sadness over the challenges of finding a suitable home.

About the author
Associate Editor
Katie Jensen is a mortgage news reporter at NMP.
Published
Sep 05, 2024
Conforming Loans Slip Below Half Of Mortgage Production

June purchase locks climbed 14% year over year while non-conforming and Non-QM lending continued gaining market share, according to Optimal Blue

Jul 09, 2026
Wealth Gap Creates Two-Speed Housing Market As Home Prices Edge Higher: Cotality

May prices increased 0.8% year over year, with equity-rich buyers fueling gains in markets like San Francisco while affordability continues to sideline many traditional borrowers

Jul 09, 2026
FICO Survey Finds Credit Confusion Still Holding Back Prospective Homebuyers

New research finds affordability remains the biggest obstacle, but many future buyers also misunderstand how credit affects mortgage eligibility and pricing

Jul 08, 2026
Lower Mortgage Payments Help Drive Home Sales Rebound: Zillow

June sales climbed 5.9% from a year earlier as mortgage costs eased, while inventory growth slowed to its weakest pace since late 2023, signaling a more balanced purchase market

Jul 08, 2026
VantageScore Says 4.0 Model Could Unlock $1 Trillion In Mortgage Originations

New study says VantageScore 4.0 scores five million more creditworthy borrowers than FICO Score 10T, expanding lending opportunities as the industry prepares for the GSE credit score transition

ROAD Act Poll Shows Support As Trump Decision Nears

Advocacy group's survey finds bipartisan backing for small-dollar mortgages and housing supply measures as the landmark housing bill awaits presidential action

Jul 07, 2026