Skip to main content

Is Gender Discrimination in Lending Rampant in Chicago?

Phil Hall
Jun 19, 2015

A new study covering home loan applications in the Chicago metro region points to a disparity between the number of men and women that receive a mortgage. However, the study’s sponsor is not rushing to declare a lethal case of Windy City gender discrimination.

The Woodstock Institute’s new study found that female home loan applicants in the six counties that make up the Chicago metro region were 14.5 percent of women were less likely to receive a mortgage than male applicants, while 28.3 percent of joint mortgage applications where the woman’s name came first were rejected versus joint applications with the man’s name first.

On the whole, an average of 81.1 percent of Chicago-area women who applied for a mortgage received the loan, while the success rate for men was 83.4 percent. But lower-income women were more likely to receive mortgages than their male counterparts.

Nonetheless, the Woodstock Institute was not eager to declare the Chicago area to be the epicenter of gender discrimination in mortgage borrowing.

"All we're saying is, this is what the data show: Female applicants are less likely to get loans originated than male applicants," said Spencer Cowan, the report’s chief researcher, in an interview with the Chicago Tribune. "We don't have basic underwriting criteria. We don't have the value of the property or any credit score range or debt-to-income ratio. We can't look at it and say cause and effect. Maybe (the report) will get the regulators' attention, maybe they will get access to better data."

Also disputing the notion of gender discrimination was Bank of America, which was cited in the report as having the most prominent data-level gender disparity, with 65.7 percent of Chicago-area female applicants and 71.2 percent of male applicants receiving mortgages.

"Valid factors in credit decisions and pricing determinations, including items such as borrower's credit history, debt-to-income ratios and loan-to-property-value ratios are not included in HMDA data," said Terry Francisco, a Bank of America spokesman, in an e-mail to the Chicago Tribune. "These legitimate credit and pricing factors drive disparities. We maintain robust compliance and monitoring procedures to ensure appropriate factors are used in credit decisions."

Jun 19, 2015
ChainLogix Appoints New Vice President, Operations

Jeryl Graham hired to accelerate growth in title & mortgage services.

Industry News
Oct 15, 2021
JPMorgan Chase To Commit $8.4M To Improve Household Stability For The Underserved

JPMorgan Chase announced six organizations that will receive philanthropic capital as part of the firm’s $400 million five-year commitment to improve housing affordability and stability for Black, Hispanic and Latino, and other underserved households.

Oct 15, 2021
SRE Mortgage Alliance 'Restructuring & Reorganizing'

Owner of technology-based wholesale residential mortgage lender in El Segundo to determine organization's future.

Oct 15, 2021
Ginnie Mae Issued Record MBS Volume In FY2021

The record $939 billion issued included nearly $73 billion in September.

Industry News
Oct 14, 2021
UWM Completes Test Of Cryptocurrency Mortgage Payments

United Wholesale Mortgage evaluated and accepted the first-ever cryptocurrency mortgage payment in September and an additional five payments in October from borrowers.

Industry News
Oct 14, 2021
Arvielo Re-Appointed To HUD Advisory Committee

Nationwide mortgage lender New American Funding’s Co-Founder and President Patty Arvielo has been re-appointed to serve on the U.S. Department of Housing & Urban Development's Housing Counseling Federal Advisory Committee.

Industry News
Oct 13, 2021