Skip to main content

PHH Challenges CFPB Authority in Court

Phil Hall
Aug 06, 2015
Courtroom Pic/Credit: Vladek

In a rare case of a mortgage industry company using the courts to fight back against the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), PHH Corp. has successfully convinced the District of Columbia U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to stay the CFPB’s final decision on a $109 million fine over alleged kickbacks.

According to a Reuters report, the three-judge panel granted PHH’s motion after determining the company “satisfied the stringent requirements for a stay pending appeal.” PHH argued that the CFPB is in violation of the federal separation-of-powers doctrine because its director, Richard Cordray, has the final word on accepting or denying appeals of the Agency’s enforcement rulings.

“The director is not answerable to the President (he is removable only for cause) or Congress (he has sole power to fund his agency from the Federal Reserve System’s operating expenses),” said PHH in its stay petition. “Never before has so much authority been consolidated in the hands of one individual shielded from the President’s control and Congress’s power of the purse.”

In responding to PHH’s challenge, the CFPB noted that a pair of companies attempted similar challenges in court–Morgan Drexen last year and ITT Educational Services earlier this year–but the courts ruled in the agency’s favor.

Aug 06, 2015
CFPB Slaps Bank Of America With $12 Million Penalty For False Mortgage Data Reporting

For at least four years, hundreds of Bank of America loan officers failed to ask mortgage applicants certain demographic questions.

Rising Home Values Propel Higher Loan Limits

FHFA Announces 5.6% Increase in Conforming Loan Limits for 2024

NMLS — Then, Now, And To Come

Leaders reminisce, plan, and dream about the regulatory group on its 15th birthday

Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac Shareholders Win Prejudgment Interest On $299M Verdict

Federal court upholds shareholders' right to interest after government's wrongful claim on profits; simple interest rate set, drawing from Delaware law precedent.

ADUs Can Now Be Sold Separately In California

‘Backyard revolution’ opens up the affordable housing market.

Cracking The Crackdown

How to eliminate and prevent ‘junk’ fees to avoid penalties