Skip to main content

California Builders Petition Supreme Court on Affordable Units Mandate

Sep 15, 2015
Affordable Housing Pic

The California Building Industry Association has filed a petition with the U.S. Supreme Court to challenge a San Jose law that mandates the inclusion of affordable housing units within all new housing developments.

According to a San Jose Mercury-News report, the builders are backed by the California Association of Realtors and the Pacific Legal Foundation (PLF) in challenging the law, which was upheld by in a unanimous ruling by the state’s Supreme Court earlier in the year. Chief Justice Tani Cantil-Sakauye stated in that ruling that San Jose's affordable housing program was necessary because the lack of affordability options “have become more and more severe and have reached what may be described as epic proportions in many of the state's localities.”

The San Jose law forces developers to set aside 15 percent of below-market rate units in new projects of 20 or more units. Developers that do not follow this mandate must pay a fee, which the builders estimate as running as high as $122,000 per development.

Brian Hodges, a PLF attorney, questioned the legality of forcing developers to set aside affordable units.

"The California Supreme Court's ruling carves arbitrary limits and loopholes in core constitutional property rights safeguards as laid down by the U.S. Supreme Court," Hodges said.

San Jose Mayor Sam Liccardo expressed his belief that the city’s law would survive a review by the nation’s highest court.

"We're confident the U.S. Supreme Court will agree with hundreds of cities like San Jose that have crafted inclusionary ordinances as a lawful and effective means to create affordable housing at a time when thousands of hard-working San Jose families face a crisis of spiraling rents," said Mayor Liccardo.

About the author
Published
Sep 15, 2015
About $18.6 Million Severance Payout For First American Ex-CEO Kenneth DeGiorgio

Rather than a brusque exit, high-performer DeGiorgio eligible to catch a soft breeze off into the horizon

Apr 23, 2025
New VantageScore Credit Model Aims To Boost Predictive Performance

Also, company’s pilot program gives nonprofit lenders access to modern credit scoring while helping them maintain sound lending practices

Apr 22, 2025
Mortgage Women Leadership Council Breaks 500-Member Benchmark

Becomes nation’s largest organization for women in the industry

Apr 21, 2025
Tug-Of-War Continues Between President Trump, Fed Chair Powell Over Rate Cuts

President’s April 17 social media post expresses growing impatience with Federal Reserve Board not cutting rates

Apr 18, 2025
Mortgage Insurance Premium Tax Write-Off Back On The Table

Bipartisan bill would restore, expand expired MIP deduction, aiming to ease homeownership costs for millions

Apr 15, 2025
FBI Boston Warns Of Growing Title Fraud

Fraudsters forging documents to sell properties or take out mortgages on them, FBI says

Apr 14, 2025