The Best and Worst SFR Markets for Investors Are... – NMP Skip to main content

The Best and Worst SFR Markets for Investors Are...

May 10, 2017
The Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) took on the challenge of updating federal housing policy again with the release of the new white paper

Yes, it’s time for another top 10 housing list—and today, the folks at HomeUnion are offering their lists for the top 10 best and worst housing markets for single-family rental (SFR) home investors during the first quarter.

 
For the 10 best list, Cleveland snagged the peak position with a cap rate of 11.5 percent and a median investment home price of $75,512. Cincinnati placed second with a 9.8 percent cap rate and a $87,092 median investment home price. Rounding out the top 10 were Columbia, S.C.
(8.6 percent cap rate, $94,372 median investment home price), Memphis (8.5 percent, $86,975), Richmond, Va. (8.2 percent, $121,682), Oklahoma City (8.2 percent, $97,960), Indianapolis (8.1 percent, $101,948), St. Louis (8.1 percent, $96,412) and Pittsburgh (eight percent, $95,489).
 
On the flip side, San Francisco was named the worst place for investors, with a cap rate of 2.8 percent and median price of nearly $1.2 million. Also among the worst places, according to HomeUnion, are San Jose (2.8 percent, $928,355), Orange County (three percent, $762,587), Los Angeles (3.4 percent, $546,177), San Diego (3.6 percent, $507,585), Seattle (3.7 percent, $439,212), Sacramento (four percent, $313,845), Salt Lake City (4.2 percent, $253,124), Oakland (4.2 percent, $488,853) and Portland (4.3 percent, $310,481).
 
“For the past two years, we have been tracking the investment and owner-occupied housing markets,” said Steve Hovland, director of research for HomeUnion. “And metros in the Midwest and Southeast always earn top billing because of their low entry prices and moderate rents. Cleveland has often ranked at the top—or near the top—of the best places to purchase SFR property. Coastal locations will be challenging for investors because median investment home prices and rents are so high, we weren’t surprised to see that investors will have to settle for nominal returns in most markets in the Bay Area, SoCal and Pacific Northwest.”

 

About the author
Published
May 10, 2017
Strong Jobs Report Threatens Mortgage Rate Rally

October hiring more than doubled expectations, pushing Treasury yields higher

Nov 06, 2026
Fed Holds Rates, But Pricing Pressures Persist

Rising Treasury yields and fresh inflation data complicate rate locks, borrower qualification, and lender margins as markets anticipate another hike in December

Oct 29, 2026
Zippy Adds Capital For Manufactured-Home Lending Push

The $20 million investment from Saluda Grade will support expansion beyond 27 states and new loan products across wholesale, retail, and community channels

Oct 16, 2026
Inflation Hits 3.7%, Putting Mortgage Rate Relief At Risk

September’s inflation pickup puts recent rate improvements at risk, potentially eroding affordability gains from lower home prices and seller concessions

Oct 14, 2026
PLACE Acquires Ardley, Expanding Push To Turn Existing Borrowers Into New Loans

The latest deal connects borrower retention technology with Maxwell's origination platform and PLACE's real estate network, creating new opportunities for lenders

Oct 09, 2026
Equifax, TransUnion Launch New Tools To Cut Credit Report Costs

Both bureaus introduce ways to purchase credit scores separately from reports, while Equifax reports growing VantageScore adoption and extends $1 pricing through 2028

Oct 09, 2026