Fed Minutes Show Mortgage Demand Weak Despite Easier Credit
Banks are easing some lending standards, but borrowers remain reluctant to take on mortgages at today's rates
Minutes from the Federal Reserve's Oct. 27–28 meeting, released Wednesday, show that mortgage credit availability continued to improve gradually even as higher interest rates kept origination activity subdued.
The Fed's staff reported that residential mortgage activity had declined further amid a sharp rise in mortgage rates. Policymakers also cited higher borrowing costs as a drag on residential investment, even as the broader economy continued to expand.
The Fed's October Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey, released Nov. 2, offers a closer look at the disconnect.
Banks reported easing lending standards for qualified mortgage (QM) jumbo, and Non-QM jumbo loans during the third quarter. Standards for most other residential mortgage categories were largely unchanged, while subprime standards tightened.
Yet banks reported weaker demand across every residential mortgage category surveyed. Demand for HELOC was essentially unchanged.
The survey included responses from 61 domestic banks and 18 U.S. branches and agencies of foreign banks. It measures changes in bank lending practices and demand, rather than originations across the entire industry.
The Fed's October meeting also offered little indication that borrowing costs would ease quickly.
Policymakers held the federal funds target range at 3.75% to 4%, while two officials favored a quarter-point increase.
According to the minutes, market pricing at the time reflected a high probability of a rate increase before year-end, with additional tightening anticipated in 2027.
Mortgage rates do not move directly with the federal funds rate, but expectations for inflation and future Fed policy influence Treasury yields and mortgage-backed securities pricing.
The Fed's findings suggest that lenders have more room to compete for certain borrowers, particularly in the jumbo market, but fewer customers ready to proceed at current financing costs.