Housing Shortage Deepens As Underbuilding Persists – NMP Skip to main content

Housing Shortage Deepens As Underbuilding Persists

Mar 03, 2026
Housing Shortage Deepens

Realtor.com economists warn that persistent underbuilding, rising household formation, and affordability barriers are delaying homeownership and could take years to meaningfully reverse

The U.S. housing supply gap widened to an estimated 4.03 million homes in 2025, according to Realtor.com’s 2026 Housing Supply Gap Report, highlighting persistent underbuilding amid strong household formation and ongoing demand.

The deficit expanded from approximately 3.8 million homes in 2024, underscoring a structural mismatch between housing supply and demand that has been building for more than a decade.

Last year saw about 1.41 million new households formed, compared with approximately 1.36 million housing starts, leaving the market with roughly 50,000 fewer units constructed than needed just in 2025.

"Even when annual construction and household formation are roughly balanced, the market is still digging out from more than a decade of underbuilding," said Danielle Hale, chief economist at Realtor.com. "A supply gap exceeding four million homes underscores how deeply rooted the shortage has become. Without a sustained and targeted increase in housing supply, particularly in areas with strong job growth and persistent demand, affordability challenges will continue to sideline many would-be buyers."

 

In 2025, the minimum recommended income to purchase a median-priced starter home was approximately $86,000, about $8,000 lower than the prior year, largely due to improved mortgage rates

 

Although the annual shortfall may seem modest in isolation, it compounds a long history of underbuilding that continues to constrain overall inventory, fuel price pressure, and make homeownership harder to reach for many Americans — particularly younger households. Realtor.com economists found that roughly 1.82 million millennial and Gen Z households were “missing” in 2025, meaning they have delayed forming independent households because of limited housing options and affordability constraints.

Affordability Remains A Major Barrier

Even with mortgage rates improving in late 2025, the minimum recommended income to purchase a median-priced starter home was about $86,000, well above the earnings of many younger buyers. The median down payment reached approximately $30,400 — equivalent to roughly 14.4% of the purchase price — meaning it could take a typical household seven years or more to save for a down payment at current savings rates.

"While construction levels remain elevated compared with historical norms, they are not yet high enough, or targeted enough, to meaningfully close the gap," said Hannah Jones, senior economic research analyst at Realtor.com. "The fact that it would take roughly seven years to eliminate the deficit even under an optimistic building scenario highlights just how significant and persistent this shortage has become."

The report notes that even under an optimistic scenario in which construction increases significantly, it would take years to meaningfully close the existing gap. Analysts warn that sustained and targeted increases in housing supply — especially in regions with strong job growth — are critical to improving affordability and giving more Americans a realistic path to homeownership.

About the author
Published
Mar 03, 2026
250 Years Of Housing Policy Shaped American Homeownership

A look back at the legislation that transformed the American dream, and what history can teach today's mortgage professionals

Jul 03, 2026
Most Homeowners Say Their Home Reflects Who They Are

Redfin survey finds homeowners value the sense of belonging and community that comes with ownership, while buyers gain more negotiating power in today's market

Jul 03, 2026
Income Gap Puts Starter Homes Out Of Reach For Most First-Time Buyers

Just 37.6% of nonhomeowner households can afford a typical starter home, according to a recent study by LendingTree

Jul 01, 2026
Home Sellers Lower Prices While Buyers Return: Realtor.com

June report points to a more balanced housing market as pending sales climb for a seventh straight month despite mortgage rates holding near 6.5%

Jul 01, 2026
Luxury Home Prices Continue To Outpace Broader Housing Market

Redfin says luxury home prices climbed 4.7% annually through May, with demand accelerating as high-end buyers remain largely insulated from affordability pressures

Jul 01, 2026
Fannie Mae Guaranty Book Slips; Delinquencies Stay Low

Single-family mortgage delinquencies edged higher in May while new business acquisitions slowed

Jul 01, 2026