Rocket, Mr. Cooper Fined $6.75M Over Cybersecurity Failures
New York regulators say Rocket repeatedly failed to report security incidents, while Mr. Cooper's attackers exploited authentication weaknesses to access customer information
Rocket Mortgage and Mr. Cooper have agreed to pay a combined $6.75 million to settle New York regulatory investigations that uncovered failures in cybersecurity reporting, authentication controls, and risk assessments, including weaknesses exploited during Mr. Cooper's massive 2023 data breach.
The New York State Department of Financial Services announced Thursday that Rocket Mortgage will pay a $2 million penalty, while Nationstar Mortgage LLC, which operated as Mr. Cooper, will pay $4.75 million.
Rocket Companies acquired Mr. Cooper in October 2025, and Nationstar subsequently merged into Rocket Mortgage LLC in February 2026. Under the settlements, Rocket Mortgage will pay the combined penalties and undertake corrective measures to strengthen its cybersecurity controls.
Rocket failed to report seven cybersecurity incidents within the required timeframe, sometimes waiting more than a year after discovering them. In six instances, the company formally notified regulators only after the incidents were uncovered during a regulatory examination.
At Mr. Cooper, attackers impersonated employees in telephone calls to the company's IT help desk, fraudulently obtained temporary passwords, and used those credentials to access company systems by bypassing multifactor authentication controls.
Regulators also found that Mr. Cooper went almost four years without completing a comprehensive cybersecurity risk assessment.
Rocket's Reporting Failures
Under New York's cybersecurity regulation, covered financial institutions must notify DFS as promptly as possible, and no later than 72 hours after determining that a reportable cybersecurity incident has occurred.
Rocket failed to meet that requirement on seven occasions involving incidents between December 2019 and August 2021, according to the department's consent order.
The incidents included business email compromises in which employees approved fraudulent authentication prompts, as well as weaknesses associated with a Microsoft Office 365 migration.
DFS also found that Rocket had failed to implement required multifactor authentication or reasonably equivalent security controls. The company lacked policies and procedures for periodically and securely disposing of consumers' nonpublic information that was no longer needed for legitimate business purposes.
The delayed reporting was a separate regulatory violation from the underlying security deficiencies. DFS said late notifications hinder its ability to assess potential risks and coordinate responses to cybersecurity incidents.
"New York's cybersecurity regulation requires covered entities to maintain strong safeguards to protect consumer data, understand evolving risks, and report cybersecurity incidents to regulators," said Acting Superintendent Kaitlin Asrow.
"The Department is committed to rigorous oversight to ensure regulated institutions protect consumers and adapt their cybersecurity programs to evolving risks."
Mr. Cooper's 2023 Breach
The $4.75 million penalty adds to the financial and legal fallout from Mr. Cooper's October 2023 cyberattack, which exposed personal information belonging to substantially all its then-current and former customers.
The latest regulatory findings provide a more detailed account of how attackers gained access.
According to DFS, the attackers used telephone impersonation to obtain temporary passwords from help desk employees. They then used those credentials to bypass multifactor authentication and access Mr. Cooper's information systems.
The department also found that Mr. Cooper had failed to complete a comprehensive cybersecurity risk assessment for almost four years, leaving the company unprepared to address evolving threats.
NMP reported in December 2023 that Mr. Cooper expected approximately $25 million in expenses for vendor services and identity protection, up from an initial estimate of $5 million to $10 million. The company had 4.3 million customers as of September 2023 and offered complimentary identity protection to current and former customers following the attack.
The legal consequences have continued.
In its third-quarter 2026 SEC filing, Rocket disclosed that litigation stemming from the breach remains pending in federal court. The case consolidates 27 proposed class-action lawsuits filed against Mr. Cooper and related entities.
A federal judge allowed negligence and breach-of-implied-contract claims to proceed while dismissing several other claims.
Rocket's latest filing said briefing on class certification was expected to be submitted Nov. 23. The company also disclosed discussions with various state regulators and attorneys general concerning investigations into the 2023 cyberattack.
What the Findings Mean
Cybersecurity failures can create regulatory exposure long after the underlying incidents have occurred.
Rocket's reporting violations involved incidents dating back to 2019, while Mr. Cooper's penalty follows a breach that occurred three years ago.
The findings put incident reporting procedures and authentication controls under renewed scrutiny. While the New York penalties stem from violations of state-specific requirements, mortgage companies nationwide face cybersecurity obligations under federal and state laws, including the FTC's Safeguards Rule.
A company may have security technology in place and still face regulatory consequences if its employees can be deceived into granting access or its procedures fail to meet applicable requirements.
Mr. Cooper's case is especially relevant to mortgage operations that depend on centralized support desks, remote employees, and third-party service providers. Authentication controls are only as effective as the procedures used to verify the people requesting access.
The Rocket findings raise a different operational concern. A company that discovers a potentially reportable incident must have a process for determining whether regulatory notification is required and ensuring that the deadline is met.
That responsibility cannot be addressed solely by fixing the technical problem that caused the incident.
Smaller mortgage companies may qualify for limited exemptions under certain cybersecurity regulations, but they are not automatically exempt from requirements to protect borrower information. Federal and state rules impose different obligations based on a company's activities, size, and regulatory status.
Additional Compliance Work
Under the consent orders, Rocket must address the deficiencies identified by regulators, including an audit of its multifactor authentication controls within 90 days. The review includes shared systems supporting core business functions.
The requirement comes as Rocket continues integrating its mortgage origination and servicing operations following the Mr. Cooper acquisition. At the end of September, the company reported a combined servicing portfolio of approximately $2 trillion in unpaid principal balance, representing 9.1 million loans.
The New York penalties resolve the enforcement matters addressed by the agreements, but they do not close the book on Mr. Cooper's 2023 breach. Federal litigation remains pending, and Rocket's latest SEC filing identifies other regulatory investigations related to the attack.
For mortgage companies handling sensitive borrower information, the cases offer a pointed warning: a security incident may be contained in days or weeks, but failures in reporting, access controls, and risk assessments can carry consequences for years.