Skip to main content

Townstone Financial Responds to CFPB's Redlining Suit Appeal

Aug 24, 2023
Courtroom Pic/Credit: Vladek
News Director

Industry attorneys forecast uphill battle for bureau which lost at district court level.

Townstone Financial has issued a rejoinder to the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's (CFPB) appeal in the ongoing redlining lawsuit that the mortgage lender has faced since 2020.

In an official response submitted on Aug. 14,  the Chicago-based mortgage lender contended that the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals should uphold the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois' decision. This prior ruling favored Townstone by rejecting the bureau's argument that an anti-discrimination law safeguards prospective borrowers.

At the time, the lower court's verdict underscored that the Equal Credit Opportunity Act exclusively pertains to home loan applicants and does not extend to potential applicants.

"It does not refer to hypothetical persons who imagine one day requesting credit," Townstone's attorneys wrote in their brief. 

The CFPB filed the lawsuit in July 2020 against Townstone Financial Inc. and its owner, Barry Sturner, claiming he and the company violated the federal Equal Credit Opportunity Act (ECOA) by making disparaging remarks about prospective loan applicants on the lender’s weekly radio show and podcast.

While the CFPB opted not to provide comments on the matter, the Mortgage Bankers Association, in an amicus brief, defended Townstone and said, "The Bureau’s expansive interpretation of Regulation B puts [MBA] members in an impossible position of trying to follow a rule that has no defined boundaries."

"In the [CFPB's] eyes, any individual could apparently be a potential applicant to a lender for credit. And in the bureau’s eyes, any statement made by a lender could be unpalatable to a prospective applicant and thus construed as an effort to discourage the prospective applicant. This wholesale ambiguity renders 12 C.F.R. § 1002.4(b) impossible to comply with," Attorney Matthew P. Previn of Paul Hastings LLC wrote. 

The legal battle began when the government watchdog initiated a lawsuit accusing Townstone of illegal redlining, alleging the mortgage company discouraged potential Black applicants from applying for home loans.

The CFPB's complaint centered on claims that between 2014 and 2017, Townstone's CEO and president made statements that discouraged individuals residing in Black neighborhoods within Chicago from seeking mortgage loans from the company.

Among these alleged remarks was the CEO's characterization of the South Side of Chicago as a "hoodlum weekend" between Friday and Monday, further suggesting that the police were the sole barrier preventing it from evolving into a "real war zone."

In February, Judge Franklin Valderrama of the Illinois federal court ruled in favor of Townstone. The case was dismissed with prejudice, which precluded the CFPB from re-filing the complaint. However, the bureau retained the right to challenge the verdict on appeal. On April 3, the CFPB notified the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals of its intent to do so without delving into the specifics of its rationale for challenging Judge Valderrama's ruling.

About the author
Christine Stuart is the news director at NMP.
Published
Aug 24, 2023
More from
Courts
Okavage Group Appeals UWM Suit Dismissal

The suit was dismissed by a Florida judge in late September

Oct 28, 2024
DOJ Sues Rocket Mortgage, Appraisal Companies

Rocket Mortgage called the suit a "massive overreach"

Oct 22, 2024
CFPB, DOJ Flag Fairway Independent For Redlining

Fairway to pay a $1.9 million penalty and provide $7 million in loan subsidies

Oct 16, 2024
UWM's Motion To Dismiss RICO Class Action Denied As Moot

Plaintiffs' late August filing of an amended complaint means UWM must file a new motion to dismiss if it wishes to proceed with having the case thrown out.

Oct 11, 2024
LoanSnap Officially Loses Connecticut License

The AI mortgage startup formerly faced a cease and desist and a consent order from the State of Connecticut.

Oct 09, 2024
Judge Grants Grella's Motion To Dismiss NEXA Lawsuit

NEXA CEO Mike Kortas confirmed that the company is prepared to file an amended complaint

Sep 27, 2024