Ask MAC: Property valuation discrepancy of more than $200,000 – NMP Skip to main content

Ask MAC: Property valuation discrepancy of more than $200,000

Dec 02, 2002

  Dear MAC: I recently originated a $1.2 million loan and was instructed to order two appraisals, which contained a property valuation discrepancy of more than $200,000. There were also differences in the square footage and selling price of one of the comparables. Have you seen this happen before, where two separate appraisers report differently on the same property? How can I remedy this problem?--Ken Rudolph, Aran Capital Dear Ken: Unfortunately, the appraisal process for super-jumbo properties is more of an art form than a science. At LUXMAC, we find that when two independent reports have been ordered simultaneously for the same property, half of them will have appraisal discrepancies. To resolve this issue, our processor or underwriter must often ask the appraiser to address or confirm the inconsistent items, usually via an addendum to the appraisal. Large adjustments to line items, such as quality of construction, time and location can vary substantially from one appraiser to the next. These grid items tend to be subjective and offer the appraiser flexibility when arriving at a valuation. Appraisers are under pressure to never over-appraise a property, because severe legal complications that may result in the event of a foreclosure or short sale. These potential consequences increase significantly with multi-million-dollar homes. Therefore, it is imperative to only utilize appraisers who are experienced in that particular market. Also, be sure to review several sample reports before giving them an order. If the appraisers are, in fact, experienced, then any subsequent requests for addendums and explanations should be fielded graciously. If not, remind them that their profession of appraising multi-million-dollar properties is not a science. They will probably agree with you. Michael A. Covino is president of the LUXMAC Home Mortgage Company. You may e-mail your super-jumbo loan questions to [email protected] or mail them to: Ask MAC c/o LUXMAC 560 White Plains Road, Suite 400 Tarrytown, NY 10591 If your question is selected for publication, you will receive a gift from the LUXMAC Home Mortgage Company.  
About the author
Published
Dec 02, 2002
More Homebuyer Assistance Programs Skip Income Caps, Accept Repeat Buyers

DPR’s Q3 report identifies 311 programs without income limits and 1,080 without first-time buyer requirements, though funded availability grew more slowly than the overall count

Oct 23, 2026
Mortgage Rate Lock-In: More High-Rate Loans, Few Signs Of A Thaw

With 30-year rates above 7% and nearly half of outstanding loans below 4%, originators face a stubborn obstacle to rebuilding repeat-buyer pipelines

Oct 22, 2026
UWM Targets The 20%-Down Myth In New Push For Brokers

Mortgage Matchup’s national campaign pitches brokers as a resource for consumers who assume their financing options are limited

Oct 21, 2026
Wholesale AEs Don’t Need More Views. They Need More Broker Conversations.

A simple shift — turning everyday broker questions into short videos — could help AEs build relationships without trying to become influencers

Oct 02, 2026
Assurance Joins Growing Push For Medical Professional Borrowers

MedPro Mortgage+ offers eligible healthcare professionals up to 100% financing without PMI as lenders expand specialty options beyond physicians

Sep 25, 2026
For LOs Using AI, More Content Isn’t The Point

Kyle Raineri shares how originators can use AI to create social media content, build borrower trust, and strengthen real estate agent relationships

Sep 24, 2026