Judge Denies Bank of America's Dismissal Request Involving HAMP Denials – NMP Skip to main content

Judge Denies Bank of America's Dismissal Request Involving HAMP Denials

Jul 08, 2011

Judge Rya Zobel has ruled that Bank of America must answer to tens of thousands of homeowners who say they were improperly denied their home loan modifications under the Home Affordable Loan Modification Program (HAMP). In her ruling, Judge Zobel denied Bank of America's motion to dismiss the case, and clarified which homeowners could continue to pursue legal claims over the bank's handling of $25 billion of taxpayer money designed to allow homeowners to avoid foreclosure. Bank of America is obligated under HAMP to offer alternatives to foreclosure and permanently reduce mortgage payments for eligible borrowers struck by financial hardship but, according to the lawsuit, the bank has not lived up to its obligation. "We have talked to hundreds of homeowners who have experienced the same bureaucratic nightmare in dealing with Bank of America," said Steve Berman, managing partner of Hagens Berman. "The vast majority tell us the same thing: Bank of America claims to have lost their paperwork, failed to return phone calls, made false claims about the status of their loan and even taken actions toward foreclosure without informing homeowners of their options." In her ruling, Judge Zobel states that the complaint "meticulously details each plaintiff's initial and ongoing compliance with all conditions" and adds "that is sufficient to defeat" Bank of America's motion to dismiss. Judge Zobel also ruled that plaintiffs living in California, Illinois, Arizona, Massachusetts, Oregon, Maryland, New Jersey, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin can pursue claims under their state laws, which often offers stronger consumer protections. The suit originally sought to represent all homeowners whose mortgages were serviced by Bank of America. Judge Zobel ruled that only those who were accepted in a TPP,  but were not given permanent HAMP modifications or written notice that their application had been denied will be allowed to continue their claims. The suit asks the court to require Bank of America to provide permanent home mortgage modifications to qualified individuals, as well as to award damages to members of the class, which includes homeowners who entered into a TPP but were wrongly denied a modification. "We are looking forward to proving that Bank of America intentionally postpones homeowners' requests to modify mortgages, depriving borrowers of federal bailout funds that could save them from foreclosure," said Berman. "The bank ends up reaping the financial benefits provided by taxpayer dollars financing TARP-funds and also collects higher fees and interest rates associated with stressed home loans."
Jul 08, 2011
Markets Anxious As Fed Opens 2-Day Meeting

Investors, mortgage brokers & bankers await latest policy statement on fighting inflation

Regulation and Compliance
Jan 25, 2022
Ginnie Mae Streamlines FHA Advanced Loan Modification program

Documentation changes eliminate requirements for recordation and title insurance.

Regulation and Compliance
Jan 24, 2022
'A Long Road To Normal'

Nominated again to lead The Fed, Powell tells Senate committee to expect three rate hikes, but 'if we have to raise interest rates more over time, we will.'

Regulation and Compliance
Jan 11, 2022
CFPB: Complaint Response Worsens At Big 3 Credit Bureaus

Report claims Equifax, Experian, and TransUnion routinely failed to fully respond to consumers with errors.

Regulation and Compliance
Jan 10, 2022
The Fed Names Chairs, Deputy Chairs For 12 Reserve Banks

In recent years, the Federal Reserve System has worked to increase the overall diversity of the Reserve Bank and branch boards of directors and continues to build on those efforts.

Regulation and Compliance
Jan 06, 2022
The Fed: Rate Hike Likely Coming in June

Federal Open Market Committee's December minutes reveal discussion of first hike in federal funds rate in 2Q of 2022, as well as of ending asset purchases by March.

Regulation and Compliance
Jan 05, 2022