Five Tips to Get a Prospect to Return Your Call – NMP Skip to main content

Five Tips to Get a Prospect to Return Your Call

Jul 06, 2015
Sales Call Pic

It can be very frustrating when you fail to get a prospect on the phone. Worse still is when your prospect doesn’t return your call after you leave a voicemail. Fortunately, there are steps that you can take to increase the likelihood that you’ll get a response from your prospect. Below we list out top five tips:

►Use multiple mediums: Everyone has a preferred method of communication—some people enjoy talking on the phone, while others prefer e-mail. Your job as a salesperson is to accommodate your prospect’s preference. When you are leaving a voicemail, indicate that you will get in touch with your prospect via e-mail, in case that works better. There are a number of people who are more likely to respond to an e-mail that can be replied to at any time of day than a phone call during certain hours.

►Send a written note: While it sounds old-fashioned, everyone enjoys getting personal mail. Send your prospects a handwritten note after meeting with them. This will increase your likeability and make prospects more likely to respond to your efforts to get in touch further down the road.

►Use referrals: If someone referred a prospect to you, make sure to name-drop when you leave a message. Knowing that you have the person who made the referral in common can motivate the prospect to return your call.  

►Schedule it: Let your prospect know the best time to contact you. For example, you might say in your message, “You can reach me between 4:00 p.m. and 7:00 p.m. Wednesday evening.” One reason people are reluctant to return calls is because they don’t want to get into a time-consuming game of phone tag. By letting the prospect know when you will be available to answer your phone, you are eliminating this concern.

►Be reassuring: It’s a good idea to let a prospect know in your voicemail that if they have decided to go with someone else’s services, that’s fine because you don’t want to pester them with follow-ups. Usually, they’ll return your call and either let you know that they have gone with someone else or tell you that they have yet to make a decision. Either way, it’s to your benefit to have this information so that if they have retained someone else’s services, you can devote your time to likelier prospects.



K. Justin Restaino is vice president of Titan List & Mailing Services Inc. For more than 15 years, he has led Titan’s Mortgage Division, helping lenders of all capacities grow their businesses utilizing targeted direct mail. With a specialized focus in refinance and purchase markets, Restaino has the insight for proper data and mail application for success. He may be reached by phone at (800) 544-8060, ext. 204 or e-mail [email protected].



This article originally appeared in the June 2015 print edition of National Mortgage Professional Magazine. 

About the author
Published
Jul 06, 2015
Jobs Report Comes In Weak After Mortgage Rates Surge

Employers added just 29,000 jobs in September, sending Treasury yields lower and offering a potential counterweight to the recent rise in mortgage rates

Oct 02, 2026
Price Cuts Hit Four-Year High As Mortgage Rates Top 7%

More than one in five listings took a price cut in September, but pending sales still posted their sharpest annual decline since March 2025

Oct 01, 2026
Serious Mortgage Delinquencies Rise 19% After Five Months Of Improvement

ICE data shows 574,000 mortgages were at least 90 days past due in August, while early-stage delinquencies remained below year-ago levels

Sep 29, 2026
Smaller Down Payments Give Buyers More Room, But Rates Limit The Savings

The typical down payment fell 9% from a year ago, while shifting market conditions are giving originators different affordability conversations across the country

Sep 25, 2026
Mortgage Rates Break 7% Just As Builders Find A Way To Move Buyers

New-home sales rose 6.4% in August as builders cut prices, offered incentives, and sold more lower-priced homes. Now mortgage rates are moving against buyers again

Sep 25, 2026
Borrowers Want Digital Closings, But Some Originators Remain Hesitant

ServiceLink finds 45% of surveyed LOs cite borrower reluctance as a barrier, even though most recent buyers say digital options would influence their choice of mortgage provider

Sep 23, 2026