The Worst Metro for First-Time Homebuyers Is … – NMP Skip to main content

The Worst Metro for First-Time Homebuyers Is …

Mar 18, 2019
Tony Bennett may have left his heart in San Francisco, but a new Bankrate.com data analysis found that relatively few first-time homebuyers will get a chance to fall in love with the Bay Area metro

Tony Bennett may have left his heart in San Francisco, but a new Bankrate.com data analysis found that relatively few first-time homebuyers will get a chance to fall in love with the Bay Area metro.
 
In a study of the nation’s 50 largest metro areas, Bankrate.com determined that San Francisco was the worst market for first-time homebuyers. Despite scoring high rankings for its cultural attractions and job market, the city scored second-to-last for affordability and market tightness and was among the bottom 10 metros for safety. California metros occupied four the bottom five worst metros for first-time homebuyers: San Francisco (ranked 50th), Los Angeles (49th) Sacramento (48th), San Jose (47th) and Seattle (46th).
 
On the flip side, Bankrate.com named Pittsburgh as the best metro for first-time homebuyers, with other top five spots going to Raleigh, N.C. (2nd), Oklahoma City (3rd), Hartford, Conn., (4th) and St. Louis (5th).
 
“Young homebuyers better be ready to compromise,” said Adrian Garcia, Data Analyst at Bankrate.com. "Affordability and convenience might be the tradeoff to moving to a major metro with a little less culture or popularity. Buyers have to find the balance that works for them and their financial situation. Make sure you’re making a sound investment. You can always upgrade later.”


 
About the author
Published
Mar 18, 2019
Congress Nears Final Vote On 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act

Senate voted 87-8 to advance House-amended package, with final votes expected in coming days

Jun 17, 2026
Florida Pending Sales Signal Strong Summer Housing Market

Closed sales rise for a ninth straight month as inventory gives buyers more negotiating power

Jun 16, 2026
Trump Taps Former CFPB Deputy Brian Johnson To Lead Bureau

MBA backs the nomination as lenders await clarity on the future direction of consumer finance regulation under the Trump administration

Jun 12, 2026
Trump Names FHFA Director Bill Pulte Acting Director Of National Intelligence

FHFA director will continue overseeing Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac while serving as acting director of national intelligence

Jun 02, 2026
Realtor.com Launches AI Home Search Platform Built With Google

New RealAssist tool combines AI, affordability guidance and Google Maps data to engage buyers before they reach lenders

Jun 02, 2026
Another MLS Challenges Zillow In Fight Over Listing Visibility

Realtracs joins MRED in pushing back on Zillow's listing policies, a battle with potential implications for the broader homebuying and mortgage ecosystem

May 29, 2026