Mortgage Ideas Don't Solve Anything – NMP Skip to main content

Mortgage Ideas Don't Solve Anything

Dec 16, 2025
Affordability Ideas Off Target
Staff Writer

The Urban Institute says innovative mortgage products like assumable, portable, or 50-year loans may improve mobility at the margins, but will not meaningfully improve affordability

Fifty-year mortgages … assumable mortgages … portable loans. They’re not gonna move the housing needle, at least not much, an independent bipartisan think-tank says. What’s needed is, in a word, more, as in more houses, the Urban Institute maintains.

“The real solution to affordability is to increase supply,” it says in a new report.

The idea for 50-year mortgages has come and gone, but assumable loans and portable loans are still on the table. Assumable loans are those in which a qualified borrower can take over the seller’s remaining loan balance at the seller’s presumably lower current rate. Portable mortgages allow the borrower to transfer their existing mortgage balance and interest rate to a new property.

As for assumable mortgages, buyers might be willing to offer more for the house because they could save hundreds a month on their house payments if they are permitted to take over the seller’s mortgage. And the higher price could induce the current owner to sell.

But assumables would need considerable accommodations to be an attractive option, the Urban Institute says. They also are likely to result “in higher monthly payments for new borrowers who aren’t assuming existing mortgages, and would not dramatically alleviate housing supply concerns.”

The think-tank outlines several shortcomings for assumable mortgages: They would apply only to future loans; appraisal issues and downpayment constraints would limit their appeal;  current mortgage rates would increase if future lock-ins are prevented; and they would not solve housing supply issues.

The Institute believes portable mortgages are the “more promising product to spur housing market liquidity” But, it says, “they face many of the same disadvantages” that confront assumable loans.

While portable loans could alleviate the lock-in effect that is blamed for keeping many people in their homes, allow owners in distress to sell more easily, and would reduce origination costs, they come with several shortcomings, the Urban Institute warns.

Like assumable mortgages, portable mortgages would apply only to new mortgages as the terms on existing securities cannot be altered. Furthermore, additional funding — perhaps a second lien — may be needed to make up for the difference between the current balance and the price of the new residence.

Unfortunately, the Institute says, neither assumable or portable mortgages “would increase the net housing supply, as almost every seller would need to buy a replacement house.”

“The real solution to affordability," the Institute argues, “is to increase supply by catalyzing new construction through changes that loosen zoning code and building regulations. The sooner policymakers address supply through cheaper and more dense construction, the quicker we can address the nation’s affordability crisis.”


About the author
Staff Writer
Lew Sichelman has been covering the housing and mortgage sectors for 52 years. His syndicated column appears in major newspapers throughout the country.
Published
Dec 16, 2025
FHA's Capital Cushion Falls to 2.65% Under Severe Stress Test

Industry groups want lower mortgage insurance premiums, but FHA's latest projections show how sharply reserves could narrow in a housing downturn

Nov 20, 2026
Housing Market May Have Found Its Bottom. What Comes Next?

NAR's latest report shows contract signings at a record low, but economists say easing mortgage rates could help stabilize purchase activity heading into 2027

Nov 19, 2026
Pending Home Sales Fall 15.3% Despite Growing Buyer Leverage

Pending sales declined across every major metro analyzed by Redfin as falling home prices and greater negotiating power failed to revive buyer demand

Nov 19, 2026
LOs Face Greater Licensing Scrutiny Than Real Estate Agents

A new report exposes gaps in real estate agent disciplinary records, raising concerns for LOs evaluating referral partners and calling for a nationwide disclosure system modeled on NMLS

Nov 17, 2026
Newrez Nears $1B in Non-QM Securitizations as Brokers Drive Volume

Two mortgage-backed securities deals totaling 1,750 loans reveal strong demand for bank-statement and DSCR lending

Nov 17, 2026
Builder Rate Incentives Give New-Home Buyers a 114-Basis-Point Edge

New-home buyers secured significantly lower starting mortgage rates than resale buyers in the third quarter

Nov 17, 2026