Rising Insurance Premiums Impact Senior Homeowners – NMP Skip to main content

Rising Insurance Premiums Impact Senior Homeowners

Associate Editor
Jul 22, 2021

Simply by monitoring, reviewing, and adjusting their insurance policy, these homeowners saved $751 annually.

KEY TAKEAWAYS
  • Increasing home insurance premiums disproportionately impacted homeowners with FICO scores below 580.
  • Home insurance premiums are on the rise nationally and grew an average of 4% year-over-year.
  • Homeowners with a FICO score below 580 experienced rising insurance premiums reaching 6.4%.
  • Premiums for seniors fail to drop because many fail to regularly check policies and annual premium increases.

Insurtech platform, Matic, released its mid-year premium trends report revealing that increasing home insurance premiums disproportionately impacted homeowners with FICO scores below 580. 

According to the 2021 mid-year report, home insurance premiums are on the rise nationally and grew an average of 4% year-over-year. However, homeowners with a FICO score below 580 experienced the largest increase in rising insurance premiums reaching 6.4%. This impacted homeowners by an extra $85 per year on average for a 12-month policy.

Ben Madick, co-founder and CEO of Matic Insurance, said, “In most states, an insurance score, which is partially driven by a credit rating, represents the probability of a claim being filed, and affects the premium a homeowner will pay for coverage.”

Rising Coverage A correlates to the overall increase in home insurance premiums. On average, Coverage A increased 6.3% year-over-year. Yet, homeowners with FICO scores below 580 saw a sharper increase of 9%.

“The housing market, the cost of materials, and the cost of labor were on the rise even before COVID-19,” Madick continued. “We're now seeing those increases reflected in the estimated replacement cost of the home (Coverage A), which ultimately drive increases in insurance premiums, among other factors. While homeowners with lower FICO scores experienced a disproportionate increase, they are receiving better coverage and the gap between premiums and Coverage A is closing.”

Although senior homeowners do not have the highest average premiums, they are the most likely to overpay and have a significant opportunity to save. The report found that homeowners over the age of 63 are the most susceptible to overpaying for home insurance. 

Matic’s data shows that average premiums tend to be the highest for those between 43 and 55 years old. But premiums for seniors fail to drop proportionately because many fail to regularly check policies and annual premium increases, adding up over time. Simply by monitoring, reviewing, and adjusting their insurance policy, these homeowners saved $751 annually. 

The study shows that 40% of homeowners have not reviewed their policy in the last two years. That is why Matic created RateReview. "We created RateReview, an insurance monitoring service, to help homeowners avoid overpayment and ensure they have the right policy,” Madick said. 

For more information visit the Matic website.

 

About the author
Associate Editor
Katie Jensen is a mortgage news reporter at NMP.
Published
Jul 22, 2021
Investor Home Purchases Hold Steady Despite Housing Market Slowdown

Realtor.com report finds investors accounted for 11.3% of home purchases in 2025, as small investors gained market share and institutional buyers continued to retreat

Jun 23, 2026
Seller Concessions Hit Record Spring High, Giving Buyers More Leverage

Nearly half of home sales included seller concessions in May, creating new opportunities for borrowers to reduce upfront costs and negotiate better terms

Jun 23, 2026
Housing Supply May Matter More Than Rates: JPMorgan

New report argues factory-built housing could lower construction costs, expand affordable inventory, and create more opportunities for first-time homebuyers

Jun 23, 2026
Best And Worst Markets For Single-Parent Homeownership

LendingTree finds single parents in some metros are more than twice as likely to own a home as those in the nation's least affordable markets

Jun 22, 2026
One-Third Of Homeowners Expect To Refinance Despite Elevated Mortgage Rates

Many prospective refinancers carry mortgage rates above 5%, suggesting demand could accelerate if borrowing costs decline

Jun 19, 2026
FHA Continues To Drive New-Home Purchase Activity

Government-backed loans accounted for more than half of builder applications for a fifth straight month as loan sizes fell and buyers remained rate-sensitive

Jun 19, 2026