Finding and Attracting Good Customers is All About Preparation – NMP Skip to main content

Finding and Attracting Good Customers is All About Preparation

May 22, 2012

Growing your business is essential, and finding those perfect prospects can be extremely difficult. The benefits of having a reliable marketing campaign are having the ability to grow at your own rate, and plan for the future no matter where the mortgage industry takes you. The following three factors MUST be considered before setting out to accomplish this task. 1. You have to be willing to pay for good customers To find out how much you have to pay, do the math: Total dollars spent with your company minus cost of goods sold. Then, subtract your desired profit margin. What you have left is a reasonable amount you could spend to acquire a new customer. The average acquisition cost per customer in the mortgage industry is between $600 and $1,200. If you’ve never done any marketing before, you might want to budget for the higher end of that. You can take that acquisition cost and multiply it by the amount of new customers you want per month to determine your monthly budget. Don’t worry if this number seems astronomically high. You will want to ramp up to that over a period of time. 2. Take a look at your sales approach Do you hard sell people your product, or do you wait for them to ask how they buy it? If you are salesperson, you'll be able to keep your acquisition costs low. If not, you are going to need to come to terms with spending more money to get someone else to do it for you. Maybe it's the marketing piece, or maybe you'll have to hire salespeople. It is always more cost-effective to do the work yourself, but anyone can have an effective marketing campaign regardless of their own sales ability. Knowing how you best sell will allow you to find the right type of marketing campaign for your own needs. 3. Dissect your close ratio Some people know this number like they know their own birthday. Others will have to calculate it. To do so, take the number of loans you closed over the last 90 days and divide that number by the total number of “leads” (or interested prospects). That will give you a reasonable close ratio. One should find themselves anywhere from five percent to 15 percent on average. Don’t think that you’re going to close any leads at 80 percent just because you can close referrals at that rate. This is marketing, not networking. Key factors that contribute to the overall success of your campaign: ►Planned growth: How many new customers you want to add every month; ►Acquisition cost: How much you can afford to spend per customer; ►Approach: The best type of marketing to work with your abilities an your budget; and ►ROI: The expected return on your investment (ROI). Now that you know where you stand, you can begin asking around about what marketing programs fit within your acquisition cost and your sales style. Talk to your colleagues about the marketing campaigns they’ve done that have worked. Direct mail, mortgage leads, live transfers, data lists, etc. … these types of campaigns are all tried and true, and will fit into most any marketing strategy. Don’t try to take this on yourself. You are a mortgage professional, not a marketing expert. So, let the pros guide you through the process: call a marketing firm, NOT A LEADS COMPANY. A marketing firm. There’s a BIG difference. You’ll want to talk with people who understand your business. There are a handful of these companies that will actually take the time to explain what works, what doesn’t and why. You'll be able to rule out certain types of marketing and advertising because they either don’t match your sales style, or they don’t match your budget. Better to know upfront than after you've spent your hard earned money. Once you find the right program, test it a few times on a small level. Don’t blow your whole marketing budget on the first trial. Test, test and re-test. Once you prove that it is profitable, THEN spend every dollar you can spare on it. In fact, you might want to consider getting another credit card because you’re going to earn a lot more money than you'll pay in interest! Bottom line: You pay $X per customer and you want X number of customers per month. If you follow this process, have a marketing firm that’s on your side and knows your goals as well as you do, you’ve identified your budget, your goals, and realistic growth for your organization, you can finally, truly, plan this growth with your marketing and feel good about the future of your organization. Good luck! Medford, Ore.-based TagQuest is a full-service marketing firm created specifically for the ever-changing business world. TagQuest assists companies with their direct marketing, advertising and branding needs, and knows what it takes to generate quality customers and, most importantly, how to retain those customers for years to come. TagQuest brings forth a unique opportunity to utilize our experience and expertise in varying consumer sales and marketing environments. For more information, call (866) 376-5540 or visit Tagquest.com.  
About the author
Published
May 22, 2012
More Homebuyer Assistance Programs Skip Income Caps, Accept Repeat Buyers

DPR’s Q3 report identifies 311 programs without income limits and 1,080 without first-time buyer requirements, though funded availability grew more slowly than the overall count

Oct 23, 2026
Mortgage Rate Lock-In: More High-Rate Loans, Few Signs Of A Thaw

With 30-year rates above 7% and nearly half of outstanding loans below 4%, originators face a stubborn obstacle to rebuilding repeat-buyer pipelines

Oct 22, 2026
UWM Targets The 20%-Down Myth In New Push For Brokers

Mortgage Matchup’s national campaign pitches brokers as a resource for consumers who assume their financing options are limited

Oct 21, 2026
Wholesale AEs Don’t Need More Views. They Need More Broker Conversations.

A simple shift — turning everyday broker questions into short videos — could help AEs build relationships without trying to become influencers

Oct 02, 2026
Assurance Joins Growing Push For Medical Professional Borrowers

MedPro Mortgage+ offers eligible healthcare professionals up to 100% financing without PMI as lenders expand specialty options beyond physicians

Sep 25, 2026
For LOs Using AI, More Content Isn’t The Point

Kyle Raineri shares how originators can use AI to create social media content, build borrower trust, and strengthen real estate agent relationships

Sep 24, 2026