LendingQB Study Finds 65 Percent of Mortgage Tech Implementations Result in Failure – NMP Skip to main content

LendingQB Study Finds 65 Percent of Mortgage Tech Implementations Result in Failure

Oct 22, 2012

LendingQB has revealed the results from its Enterprise Process Assessment (EPA), engagements with clients and prospects, which is a workflow evaluation model designed that helps lenders make objective decisions on their technology initiatives. LendingQB developed the Enterprise Process Assessment (EPA) as a tool to help lenders fully understand the drivers that motivate technology improvement efforts. "Research shows that upwards of 65 percent of complex software implementations result in failure," said David Colwell, vice president of corporate strategy at LendingQB. "Even for implementations that do succeed, more than a third of these projects go over budget. The goal of the EPA is to help lenders avoid being one of these statistics and achieve an optimal ROI that effectively addresses the technology goals they have in mind." LendingQB unveiled their EPA model earlier this year, and conducted a series of Webinars over the summer to help lenders objectively evaluate mortgage technologies. The EPA model engages lenders through in-depth interviews with lending executives and management, and is followed by detailed mapping of a lender's unique workflow, which then provides a framework for LendingQB to construct a custom survey that gathers productivity assessments from the lender's staff. A statistical analysis is then applied to identify key improvements and correlate data along with recommended technology objectives and a clear path forward roadmap. EPA findings show that: ►Lenders tend to focus on surface-level features instead of addressing solutions to underlying problems. ►There are typically five major productivity bottlenecks that lenders try to address with new technology. ►Prioritization of features is determined using subjective methods instead of relying on objective or empirical data such as productivity improvement. ►Stakeholder input is typically gathered top-down versus bottom-up. ►Vendor evaluations focus primarily on system functionality and give less weight to system utilization. The EPA provides lenders with a balanced and objective perspective on a vendor’s complete technology stack and uncovers issues that are not readily apparent to management. "Even large organizations that can produce detailed RFPs are not immune to what I term 'feature enamored syndrome,' or poor weighting of technology demands," said Colwell. "We designed the EPA to be as an aid to existing evaluation methods. As a company that has successfully implemented systems for hundreds of financial institutions, our value to lenders is more than the systems we build. We want to contribute to a lender's success, whether they use our technology or not."
About the author
Published
Oct 22, 2012
More from
Tech
ALTA Opens Title Standards to AI for First Time

Land title association's agreement with Orbital gives AI access to official forms and survey standards

Nov 12, 2026
Younger Borrowers Want More Personal Guidance Despite Digital Gains

Nearly half say their lender representative should have been more involved, while fewer borrowers overall receive same-day answers, JD Power finds

Nov 10, 2026
When AI Takes Action: New Federal Framework Raises Questions

New federal banking guidance examines the risks of autonomous AI, from borrower communications to servicing transactions, with a focus on human oversight and accountability

New Integration Aims to Cut Construction Loan Draw Delays

Sitewire and Nexys connect loan origination with budget reviews and inspections, aiming to speed draw approvals and improve oversight for private lenders

Nov 10, 2026
New AI-Run Mortgage Startup Builds Database Of 224,000 LOs

LenDb.ai is making LO records available to AI assistants, offering a potential new way for borrowers to find originators

Nov 05, 2026
Gateway Taps ICE For Servicing Overhaul After $2.4B MSR Sale

The lender is consolidating servicing operations on ICE's MSP platform after disclosing regulatory capital constraints that have limited its ability to retain MSRs

Nov 05, 2026