First American Predicts A Longer 'Housing Winter' – NMP Skip to main content

First American Predicts A Longer 'Housing Winter'

Feb 18, 2025
Cool housing market
Associate Editor

Home prices, rates, and property taxes all expected to affect homebuyer decisions in 2025

Home prices are now about 55% higher compared to pre-pandemic levels (February 2020), according to the First American Data & Analytics Home Price Index (HPI) for the month of January. However, the pace of growth in national home prices has hit its slowest pace since the summer of 2023 amid elevated mortgage rates and rising inventories. 

“Elevated mortgage rates reduce house-buying power for potential buyers, holding back demand,” explains First American Chief Economist Mark Fleming. “At the same time, inventory levels are increasing as some potential sellers list their homes for sale after coming to terms with ‘higher-for-longer’ rates and more new-home completions hit the market, further dampening price growth.”

As the Fed continues its higher-for-longer interest rate policy, Fleming believes the housing market will, in turn, remain cooler-for-longer. “Much like the groundhog seeing its shadow, we expect this ‘housing winter’ to persist if mortgage rates remain high while inventories keep climbing,” he added.

Property taxes are also significantly affecting homebuyer affordability, nationwide. WalletHub provides a list illustrating which U.S. states are currently tax-friendly and which ones are not.   

Luxury Home Price Growth Outperforms Other Market Tiers

At the metropolitan level, home sales prices within local markets are separated into three tiers: the starter tier represents home sales prices at the bottom third of the market price distribution; the mid-tier represents home sales prices in the middle third of the market price distribution; and the luxury tier represents the top third of the market price distribution.

Home prices in the luxury tier grew in 25 of the 28 markets First American tracked in January, outpacing price growth in the mid- and starter tier segments. Flemings finds this unsurprising, considering luxury homebuyers more often tend to pay for home purchases in cash. However, a recent Redfin report notes a declining portion of cash-heavy homebuyers compared to other years. 

“Luxury home buyers, less affected by the lock-in effect due to their ability to pay in cash, are playing a different game,” Fleming said. 

December’s existing-home sales report found the boom in sales was most distinct at the upper end of the market as sales of homes priced at more than $1 million jumped 35%, nationally, followed closely by homes in the $750,000-$1 million range, which spiked 33%. 

“Existing homeowners are playing ‘housing musical chairs’ by selling to each other, a dynamic that is keeping luxury price growth strong in many markets,” Fleming added.

Property Taxes By State 

Property taxes have also had a growing influence over homebuyers in terms of where and when to buy a home. In January 2025, CoreLogic reported that property taxes grew 15.4%, nationally, since before the pandemic.

Today, WalletHub released its 2025’s Property Taxes by State report, illustrating which state residents pay the most in property taxes relative to their state.

The average American household spends $2,969 on property taxes for their homes each year, according to the U.S. Census Bureau, and residents of the 26 states with vehicle property taxes tack on another $492. That includes renter households that pay property taxes directly or indirectly.

Hawaii has the lowest real estate tax in the U.S., which is 8.3 times lower than in New Jersey, the state with the highest real estate taxes. The states with the lowest real estate taxes, per WalletHub’s data, are Alabama, Nevada, Colorado, and South Carolina.

States with the highest real estate taxes are New Jersey, followed by Illinois, Connecticut, New Hampshire, and Vermont.

Additionally, the report found that Blue States were found to have 28.35% higher real-estate property taxes, averaging $3,423, than Red States, averaging $2,667.

About the author
Associate Editor
Katie Jensen is a mortgage news reporter at NMP.
Published
Feb 18, 2025
Existing-Home Sales Hit 16-Year Low, More Declines May Be Ahead

October sales plunged 5.5% as high mortgage rates sidelined buyers, with economists warning the slowdown could extend into November and December closings

Nov 13, 2026
Income Calculation Errors Drive Mortgage Quality Concerns

An ACES Quality Management report finds that critical mortgage defects declined in the second quarter, even as income calculation errors, borrower eligibility issues, and appraisal findings increased

Nov 12, 2026
Even at 6%, Mortgage Rates May Not Be Enough to Unlock Home Sales

New Realtor.com analysis finds that moving would still increase the typical homeowner's mortgage payment by nearly 62%

Nov 11, 2026
Younger Borrowers Want More Personal Guidance Despite Digital Gains

Nearly half say their lender representative should have been more involved, while fewer borrowers overall receive same-day answers, JD Power finds

Nov 10, 2026
Mortgage Locks Plunge 19% Despite Rate Relief, ARM Share Hits New High

October's sharp decline in lending activity points to a tougher purchase market, even as borrowers turn to ARMs, FHA, and Non-QM financing

Nov 10, 2026
Condo Sellers Outnumber Buyers 2 to 1 as Financing Pressures Mount

Redfin reports the widest condo market imbalance in 13 years, giving buyers more negotiating power

Nov 10, 2026