Newrez Pilot Offers Early Test Case As GSEs Open Door To VantageScore 4.0, FICO 10T – NMP Skip to main content

Newrez Pilot Offers Early Test Case As GSEs Open Door To VantageScore 4.0, FICO 10T

Apr 28, 2026
Newrez Pilot Offers Early Test Case
VP of Content

Initial securitized loans with Freddie Mac highlight operational questions following Federal Housing Finance Agency policy shift

A batch of loans originated by Newrez and delivered to Freddie Mac is providing one of the first real-world examples of how alternative credit-scoring models could function within the agency mortgage system.

The loans, about $10 million in volume, according to Bill Pulte, director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency (FHFA), were underwritten using VantageScore 4.0 as part of an initial pilot and have since been securitized. Pulte referenced the pilot during a recent press conference following the FHFA’s announcement that the government-sponsored enterprises will begin accepting mortgages assessed using both VantageScore 4.0 and FICO 10T.

That FHFA decision marked a significant shift in credit policy for the conforming market, where legacy FICO models have long been the standard. The move is intended to introduce competition and incorporate newer scoring approaches, including trended credit data.

Pilot Highlights Operational Path

While the policy change has broad implications, the Newrez-Freddie Mac pilot is notable primarily for demonstrating that loans using VantageScore 4.0 can move through the full agency pipeline — from origination to securitization.

That addresses a key industry question: not whether alternative scores are permitted, but whether they can be executed within existing GSE frameworks without disrupting underwriting, delivery, and secondary market processes.

At roughly $10 million, the pilot represents a limited sample size relative to overall agency production. But its completion suggests that at least one lender has worked through the mechanics required to deliver these loans in practice.

What The FHFA Decision Changes

Under the FHFA’s updated framework, lenders will be able to use VantageScore 4.0 and FICO 10T for loans delivered to the GSEs, though implementation timelines and operational requirements are still developing.

Both models incorporate trended credit data, which evaluates borrower behavior over time rather than relying solely on a snapshot of current balances and payment history. Supporters argue this can improve risk assessment and potentially expand the number of scorable borrowers.

However, the transition also introduces complexity. Lenders may need to manage multiple scoring models, adjust underwriting guidelines, and account for differences in how loans are priced or evaluated by investors.

What Originators Should Watch

The immediate impact is less about volume and more about direction.

The pilot cited by FHFA leadership shows that loans using VantageScore 4.0 are already moving through the system, albeit in limited numbers. The broader question is how quickly lenders adopt the models and how investors respond as volume increases.

In the near term, LOs should expect a transition period where both legacy and new scoring models coexist, with evolving guidelines from the GSEs shaping how and when each is used.

The larger takeaway: credit score modernization is no longer theoretical, but the pace and scale of adoption will depend on how quickly lenders can operationalize the change beyond early pilots.

 

About the author
VP of Content
Czarinna Andres is Vice President of Content at NMP, where she leads editorial strategy, content development, and coverage of the trends, policies, and business decisions shaping the industry. Her work focuses on delivering…
Published
Apr 28, 2026
More from
Operations
Chase Wants Nonbanks' Mortgage Business. It Also Helps Finance Them.

Chase is targeting nonbank lenders for market share, even as its correspondent and warehouse businesses maintain financial ties to the sector

Nov 18, 2026
Better's Purchase Lending Push Tops $266M in Recent Team Additions

Two more purchase-heavy teams join NEO Home Loans as Better courts experienced LOs with tech and lead gen

Nov 13, 2026
HUD Renews Social Security Data-Sharing Framework for FHA Loans

The 18-month agreement takes effect Dec. 3 and covers identity verification for borrowers and non-borrowing spouses, including responses when identifying information fails to match federal records

Nov 12, 2026
FICO vs. VantageScore: Lenders Gain More Options to Qualify Borrowers

Informative Research reports active use of Classic FICO and VantageScore 4.0 as lenders expand scoring options

Nov 09, 2026
Pennymac Made $29M. Its Origination Business Lost Money.

Servicing kept the lender profitable in the third quarter as production volume plunged and management accelerated a $160 million cost-reduction plan

Nov 03, 2026
CrossCountry Widens VantageScore Eligibility, Reports $2,500 In Savings

Lender reports a 62-basis-point reduction in loan-level pricing adjustments for qualifying transactions and removes an 80% LTV restriction as alternative credit scoring gains traction

Oct 29, 2026