Homebuying Pessimism Grows, Affordability Woes Persist – NMP Skip to main content

Homebuying Pessimism Grows, Affordability Woes Persist

Feb 07, 2025
Majority of Americans struggle to make housing payments: Redfin
Associate Editor

On the bright side, household incomes have achieved some stability

With broader consumer confidence declining in January, the latest update to the Fannie Mae Home Purchase Sentiment Index (HPSI) shows an increase of 0.3 points in January to 73.4, marking a slight recovery after homebuying sentiment fell last month for the first time since July.

Improved optimism toward both homebuying and home-selling conditions, along with even greater expectations that home prices will rise throughout 2025, drove the small increase.

“Consumers seem increasingly pessimistic that housing affordability conditions will improve across the board, as a growing share expects home prices, rent prices, and mortgage rates will all go up,” said Kim Betancourt, Vice President of Multifamily Economics and Strategic Research. 

After a surge in mortgage rate optimism in the second half of 2024, the net share of consumers who believe mortgage rates will go down in the next 12 months declined 13 percentage points in January 2025. 

In addition, the share of consumers who expect rental prices to go up increased 8 percentage points from last month to 65%. Compared to last year, the HPSI is up 2.7 points.

“The lower optimism toward the mortgage rate outlook was largely expected, as rates have continued to stay elevated and even crossed the 7% threshold in mid-January,” Betancourt added. “As noted in our latest forecast, we currently expect mortgage rates to end 2025 around 6.5%, relatively little changed from where we are today, which will likely continue to hinder relief for housing affordability and home sales activity.”

A Good Or Bad Time To Buy?

Respondents weighed in on whether or not they believe it’s a good time or bad time to purchase a home, and the pessimists (bad time) won in a landslide (78%) compared to the optimistic party (22%). Both showed the same results from the prior month.

However, the net share of those who say it is a good time to buy increased 2 percentage points from the previous month to -55%.

On the home selling front, 63% of respondents say it is a good time to sell a home while 36% say it’s a bad time to sell. Both were unchanged from the previous month.

But, the net share of those who say it is a good time to sell increased 1 percentage point month over month to 28%.

Home Price & Rate Expectations

Consumers were somewhat more optimistic about home prices in January, with the percentage of respondents believing home prices will increase in 2025 rising from 38% to 43%.

The optimistic party is losing support as the percentage of those who believe home prices will go down this year fell from 27% to 22%. 

The neutral party, who believe home prices will stay the same, decreased from 35% to 34%. As a result, the net share of those who say home prices will go up in the next 12 months increased 9 percentage points from the month prior to 20%.

Fewer respondents think mortgage rates will go down in the next 12 months, decreasing from 42% to 35%. Some of those respondents moved into the pessimistic camp, with the percentage of respondents who think rates will rise in 2025 increased from 25% to 32%.

Others moved over to the neutral camp, which increased from 32% to 33%, believing rates will stay the same.

Job Security & Income

Respondents were also more optimistic about job security. The percentage of respondents who say they are not concerned about losing their job in the next 12 months increased from 77% to 78%, and the same percentage of respondents (22%) remain worried about losing their jobs.

The net share of respondents who are optimistic about job security increased 2 percentage points month over month to 56%.

Likewise, household income has achieved some stability. The percentage who say their household income is significantly higher than it was 12 months ago remained at 17%. Yet, the percentage who say their household income is significantly lower declined from 11% to 9%. 

Meanwhile, the percentage who say their household income is about the same increased from 70% to 73% — a new survey high.

As a result, the net share of those who say their household income is significantly higher than it was 12 months ago increased 2 percentage points month over month to 8%.

About the author
Associate Editor
Katie Jensen is a mortgage news reporter at NMP.
Published
Feb 07, 2025
Existing-Home Sales Hit 16-Year Low, More Declines May Be Ahead

October sales plunged 5.5% as high mortgage rates sidelined buyers, with economists warning the slowdown could extend into November and December closings

Nov 13, 2026
Income Calculation Errors Drive Mortgage Quality Concerns

An ACES Quality Management report finds that critical mortgage defects declined in the second quarter, even as income calculation errors, borrower eligibility issues, and appraisal findings increased

Nov 12, 2026
Even at 6%, Mortgage Rates May Not Be Enough to Unlock Home Sales

New Realtor.com analysis finds that moving would still increase the typical homeowner's mortgage payment by nearly 62%

Nov 11, 2026
Younger Borrowers Want More Personal Guidance Despite Digital Gains

Nearly half say their lender representative should have been more involved, while fewer borrowers overall receive same-day answers, JD Power finds

Nov 10, 2026
Mortgage Locks Plunge 19% Despite Rate Relief, ARM Share Hits New High

October's sharp decline in lending activity points to a tougher purchase market, even as borrowers turn to ARMs, FHA, and Non-QM financing

Nov 10, 2026
Condo Sellers Outnumber Buyers 2 to 1 as Financing Pressures Mount

Redfin reports the widest condo market imbalance in 13 years, giving buyers more negotiating power

Nov 10, 2026