Lenders Swing to Losses as MBA Warns of More Job Cuts
Production costs rose despite falling loan volume, raising fresh concerns about staffing and profitability heading into 2027
Independent mortgage lenders swung back into production losses during the third quarter, prompting the Mortgage Bankers Association (MBA) to warn that staff reductions and other cost-cutting measures could accelerate through early 2027.
Lenders reported an average pre-tax production loss of $30 per loan, compared with a $973 profit in the second quarter, according to MBA's quarterly performance report released Tuesday.
The $1,003 swing came during what has historically been the industry's strongest quarter, with production costs climbing even as lenders originated fewer loans.
"Average pre-tax net production income reached its lowest level for a third quarter since 2023. The results are particularly disappointing given that the third quarter has historically been the strongest quarter of the year," said Marina Walsh, MBA's vice president and head of industry analysis.
Staffing Levels Lag Declining Volume
Average loan production expenses increased $679 per loan, reaching $11,615, while production revenue fell $324 to $11,585.
Meanwhile, the average number of loans originated per company declined to 1,848 from 1,958 in the previous quarter, a 5.6% decrease.
Despite the slowdown, production staffing remained relatively flat from the second quarter and exceeded year-earlier levels.
"Staff reductions and other cost-cutting measures may accelerate the rest of this year and in the first quarter of 2027," Walsh said.
The findings echo concerns raised in loanDepot's recent third-quarter earnings report, when CEO Anthony Hsieh acknowledged that the lender's operating costs were designed for substantially higher production volumes.
loanDepot reported a $28.7 million quarterly loss and outlined additional cost reductions as it works toward profitability in 2027.
The broader industry figures suggest renewed pressure on branch economics, recruiting expenses, and production staffing as lenders attempt to bring costs in line with demand.
Servicing Provides a Financial Cushion
Net servicing financial income more than doubled to $195 per loan serviced, up from $80 in the second quarter, as slower prepayments and higher mortgage servicing rights valuations supported earnings.
Even with that benefit, only 59% of mortgage companies reported an overall pre-tax profit, down sharply from 85% in the previous quarter.
Without servicing operations, just 44% would have been profitable.
The gap illustrates the financial advantage servicing income can provide when origination margins deteriorate, although the benefit depends partly on mortgage servicing rights valuations.
The findings also highlight a difficult outlook for production-focused lenders without substantial servicing portfolios.
MBA's report included production data from 335 companies, 82% of which were independent mortgage companies.
With production costs rising, staffing slow to adjust, and the traditionally strong third quarter ending in losses, lenders face mounting pressure to reduce expenses heading into 2027.