Two Signing Bonuses. One Six-Hour Drive. – NMP Skip to main content

Two Signing Bonuses. One Six-Hour Drive.

Nov 16, 2026
Two Signing Bonuses. One Six-Hour Drive.
Director of Sales and Marketing, Northern Mortgage

A mortgage recruiter explains why winning over LOs takes more than money and what lenders can learn about keeping their top producers

"This other offer is pretty tempting."

A loan officer told me that while deciding between our company and two competitors. I appreciated the honesty. One company had offered him a sizable signing bonus. The other had a decent bonus on the table, too.

We weren't offering one.

Both companies had talked shop with him. They'd discussed compensation, held Zoom calls, and made their pitches. Neither had met him in person.

I'd already met him a couple of times. I've always made a point of meeting someone face-to-face before hiring them. Maybe that's old-school, but I'm not comfortable asking somebody to make a major career move based entirely on a video call.

When he told me how tempting the offer was, I didn't try to convince him the money didn't matter. Of course it mattered. I asked him something else.

"Did they talk to you about you? Your goals, your family, what you'd need to accomplish what you're trying to do?"

"Not in that detail," he said.

I suggested dinner the next evening and asked him to bring his wife. He could pick the restaurant.

He reminded me it was about a six-hour drive and said I didn't need to come all that way.

"Yes, I do. And I'm more than happy to."

So I went.

What he told me afterward has stuck with me.

"It felt like you got me. You wanted me to hit my goals. You wanted to learn more about me than my volume."

We'd talked about those goals: building his own office, growing his business, and creating more options for his family. Sure, we discussed pricing and operations, too. He needed to know the company could help him succeed. A good dinner won't rescue a bad mortgage platform.

But I knew his wife's name and his two daughters' names. I knew why he'd become a loan officer and what he was working toward beyond next month's closings.

About two weeks after dinner, he joined our company. He's already hired his first loan officer and is building toward the office he told me about that night.

I don't claim dinner alone made his decision. But the experience showed me how easily our industry gets recruiting backward: We can tell you a producer's volume down to the dollar before we know much about the person behind it.

Know Why You're Leaving

I've spent years talking with loan officers considering a change. Ask why they're looking, and compensation often comes up first. That's fair. Nobody should feel guilty about wanting to earn more for the business they bring in.

Keep talking, though, and you may hear something else. A manager who stopped returning calls. Underwriting turn times that have them apologizing to Realtors. Pricing that makes it tough to win deals.

Other loan officers aren't particularly unhappy. They've simply outgrown the room they're in. They want to hire a team, build a branch, or run their business with more autonomy.

Those aren't interchangeable problems. More basis points won't make underwriting faster. A signing bonus won't create a management team that listens. On the other hand, great operations don't excuse a compensation plan that no longer makes sense.

Before you change companies, figure out which problem you're actually trying to solve.

I've had recruiting conversations where we've gone through pricing, agreements, turn times and everything a loan officer says isn't working. After all that, I ask one question.

"Have you told your manager?"

Sometimes the answer is no.

Think about that. Someone is considering changing companies, disrupting a pipeline and potentially putting referral relationships at risk, but hasn't clearly told their own employer what's wrong.

I've advised plenty of those people to have that conversation before we go any further. Tell your manager what's happening. Give them examples, explain what you need, and let them respond.

Maybe they fix it. Maybe they don't. If they've made the same promises six times and nothing changes, you have every right to consider other options. I'm not suggesting anyone sit around indefinitely hoping things get better.

But if your company doesn't know what you need, you haven't really given it a chance to earn your business again.

Some people might find that strange advice from a recruiter. I don't. If a loan officer stays because the problems get addressed, that's a good outcome. If nothing changes, we can have a more informed conversation about what comes next.

Look Beyond the Signing Bonus

When it's time to explore another offer, don't just compare the checks. Ask to see actual pricing scenarios. Talk with processors, underwriters, and loan officers who've lived through a difficult closing or two, not just the executives introducing themselves on Zoom. Understand the agreements you're signing, including repayment obligations and restrictions.

A bad move can cost months of rebuilding, lost production and referral relationships you've spent years developing.

And ask the question that doesn't fit neatly on a compensation worksheet: What happens when something goes wrong on a Friday afternoon?

That's when you'll learn what access to management and operational support really means.

For mortgage leaders, there's an uncomfortable side to this story. We invest time and money in attracting producers, study their production reports, and forecast what they'll bring over. Yet sometimes the first person to ask one of our own loan officers what they want to accomplish in the next three years is a recruiter from another company.

When was the last time you asked one of your own producers what they want in three years, not what they'll close next month?

We shouldn't need a resignation letter to start that conversation.

I drove six hours to have dinner with a loan officer and his wife. I don't expect every recruiter to do that, and I know good relationships can begin remotely. The distance isn't the lesson. Taking the time to understand the person is.

If you lead loan officers, you may not need to get in a car at all. You might just need to pick up the phone.

Because the next person considering a move could be someone you already employ.

About the author
Director of Sales and Marketing, Northern Mortgage
Tim Enbody is the Director of Sales and Marketing at Northern Mortgage in Grand Rapids, Michigan, where he has spent the last 12 years of a sales career that spans more than 25 years. He is the founder and host of Elevate With…
Published
Nov 16, 2026
More from
Opinion
Two Signing Bonuses. One Six-Hour Drive.

A mortgage recruiter explains why winning over LOs takes more than money and what lenders can learn about keeping their top producers

Nov 16, 2026
Homeownership Is Increasingly Elusive for Gen Z

CHLA calls for changes to condo financing, manufactured housing loans, and down payment assistance to revive the first-time homebuyer market

Nov 12, 2026
DSCR Lending Keeps Gaining Ground as Investor Purchases Slow

As investor purchases decline, DSCR loans capture a growing share of Non-QM lending, creating opportunities for brokers who understand the differences between lender programs

Nov 11, 2026
Remember The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau?

Despite staffing cuts, legal challenges, and a lower public profile, the CFPB remains a consequential force in residential lending

Nov 05, 2026
Behind The Non-QM Numbers: How Experienced Originators Choose The Right Income-Documentation Path

How choosing the right income-documentation method upfront can help originators avoid costly delays, underwriting setbacks, and missed opportunities in Non-QM lending

Oct 30, 2026
I Told A Borrower His Credit Was Crap. The Real Problem Was Me.

After years of chasing production numbers, one mortgage sales veteran learned that closing deals means little if you lose the trust of the people behind them

Oct 29, 2026