Housing Market May Have Found Its Bottom. What Comes Next?
NAR's latest report shows contract signings at a record low, but economists say easing mortgage rates could help stabilize purchase activity heading into 2027
The housing market may finally be approaching the bottom of its current downturn, but the bigger question is how long it could remain there.
Pending home sales fell 4.7% in October to their lowest level since the National Association of Realtors (NAR) began tracking the data in 2001. Contract signings were down 16.7% from a year earlier, marking the second consecutive month of record-low activity.
Yet NAR Chief Economist Lawrence Yun sees a possible turning point.
"October could mark the low point in contract signings for this housing cycle, as mortgage rates appear to have topped out," Yun said.
A bottom, however, doesn't necessarily mean a rebound is close.
Sam Williamson, senior economist at First American, offered a similarly cautious outlook, suggesting October likely marked a low point but warning that affordability remains a formidable obstacle.
"Pending home sales fell to a record low for the second consecutive month in October, as higher mortgage rates sapped buyer demand," Williamson said. "While rates have since pulled back, strained affordability is likely to keep sales sluggish, leaving life events to drive moves while other buyers wait for better conditions."
A Bottom Without a Bounce?
The possibility of a prolonged period of depressed sales presents a challenge for lenders preparing their 2027 production forecasts.
Mortgage rates climbed to approximately 7.4% in October before retreating, according to Freddie Mac data. But the subsequent improvement has yet to establish a sustained recovery in purchase activity.
The latest Redfin figures show pending sales down 15.3% annually during the four weeks ending Nov. 15, suggesting that contract activity remained exceptionally weak even after mortgage rates retreated from their October peak.
The concern is that a stabilization in rates may stop purchase demand from deteriorating without generating enough additional transactions to materially improve production.
Williamson expects life events to remain a primary driver of home purchases, while homeowners considering discretionary moves and some first-time buyers continue to wait for more favorable conditions.
Higher incomes and slower home-price growth could eventually restore some purchasing power, he said, but elevated borrowing costs would continue to limit the improvement in sales.
What Would Signal a Recovery?
The first sign of a turnaround would be pending sales stabilizing after two consecutive record lows. But for lenders, the more encouraging development would be a sustained increase in purchase mortgage applications, followed by stronger contract signings and closings.
That could take time. Even if October proves to be the cyclical bottom, affordability constraints and homeowners' reluctance to surrender low-rate mortgages could keep transaction volumes depressed well into 2027.
"Two consecutive months of record-low pending contracts point to very sluggish fourth-quarter home sales closings, and annual existing-home sales could be the lowest since the mid-1990s," Yun said.
A bottom in contract activity could be an encouraging first step, even if the recovery is gradual. Easing mortgage rates may bring some sidelined buyers back into the market, while improving affordability could help more preapproved borrowers move forward with purchases. The next few months should offer a clearer picture of whether October marked the beginning of a sustained improvement in purchase demand.