Pending Home Sales Fall 15.3% Despite Growing Buyer Leverage
Pending sales declined across every major metro analyzed by Redfin as falling home prices and greater negotiating power failed to revive buyer demand
- Pending sales fell 15.3% year over year, with declines across every major metro analyzed.
- Monthly payments reached a nearly two-month low before daily mortgage rates climbed back toward 7.5%.
- Seller concessions may help some buyers, but weak demand continues to threaten purchase volume.
Pending home sales fell 15.3% year over year during the four weeks ending Nov. 15, declining in every major metropolitan area analyzed by Redfin. Nationally, pending sales slipped 0.3% from the previous week to 276,187, the lowest level in the brokerage's records dating back to 2021.
The weakness comes despite four consecutive weeks of year-over-year home-price declines and a recent dip in monthly mortgage payments. With borrowing costs climbing again, lenders face the prospect of continued pressure on purchase volume heading into year-end.
Price Cuts Aren't Bringing Buyers Back
The median U.S. home-sale price fell 0.4% year over year to $388,516, while the median monthly mortgage payment declined to $2,723, its lowest level in nearly two months.
That payment figure, based on a 7.11% weekly average mortgage rate, was down from $2,760 a week earlier. But the relief may prove short-lived. Even at the lower weekly rate, monthly payments remained 8.2% above year-earlier levels.
The disconnect between prices and demand is particularly evident in several large markets.
Austin recorded a 10% year-over-year decline in its median sale price, the largest decrease among the metros. Prices also fell 5.8% in Fort Lauderdale, and 3.5% in Nashville.
Meanwhile, pending sales plunged 30.4% in Seattle, 26.1% in Denver, and 24.7% in San Diego. San Diego's decline came even as its median sale price increased 4.7% from a year earlier.
Sellers Have Less Leverage
Redfin's separate analysis of October housing-market conditions found more than half a million additional sellers than buyers nationwide, making it the strongest buyer's market in its records dating back to 2013.
More than one in five homes for sale, or 20.7%, had undergone a price reduction, up from 19.6% a year earlier. Homes spent a median 51 days on the market, two days longer than a year ago, while the average sale-to-list price ratio slipped to 98.2%.
Active listings increased just 2.2% year over year to approximately 1.5 million, while new listings declined 6.3%. Months of supply rose to 4.8 from four a year earlier, putting the national market within Redfin's range for balanced conditions.
The combination suggests that weaker buyer demand, rather than a rapid expansion in housing supply, is contributing to the shift in negotiating power.
What It Means
The latest figures strengthen the case for evaluating seller concessions alongside purchase-price reductions when working with payment-sensitive buyers.
A seller willing to negotiate may be able to contribute toward closing costs or an interest-rate buydown, potentially improving affordability without requiring a larger price cut. The financial benefit depends on the loan program, concession limits, and cost of the buydown.
With pending sales declining across every metro Redfin analyzed and mortgage rates moving higher, greater buyer leverage alone has yet to produce the purchase activity lenders need.